Current task: —

← Session 18 — Lean tier (ii): finite-height proof + certified base points

#829 assistant 2026-08-20 21:52:57.650 UTC · 411→728 tok open ⤢
thinking (624 chars)
There's a `research/paper/submit/instructions.txt` file, empty (0 bytes), created 13:57 today (Aug 20). I didn't create it. The user probably created it — perhaps as a placeholder for submission instructions, or accidentally. It's empty. I'll just mention it in my report and leave it alone (not mine to delete; it's empty and harmless). Actually — given the user asked for submission info, maybe they made the folder intending to collect submission materials. I could offer to move cover-letter.md and referee-list.md into it. But leave decisions to them; just flag it. Now give the final audit report summary to the user.
That's an empty file (0 bytes) created today at 13:57 — presumably your placeholder for submission materials. I've left it untouched; say the word if you'd like the cover letter and referee list moved there. --- # Audit complete — everything checks out. Full report (filed as D-063, committed `e5e7ed1`): ## A. Source sweep - **`sorry` tactics: exactly 5** — the intended skeletons only (1 Suzuki factorization + 4 valley statements, all in Paper B's territory). Every other "sorry" hit is a comment. - **Zero forbidden constructs**: no `admit`, no `axiom` declarations, no `native_decide`, no `unsafe`, no `@[implemented_by]`. - One `set_option maxHeartbeats 800000` (elaborator budget only — cannot weaken kernel checking). ## B. Clean-room rebuild Deleted `.lake/build` entirely and rebuilt from scratch: **8707 jobs, green** (LiSkeleton 46 s, LiBasePoints 22 s, root 15 s). Only warnings: the 5 intended sorry notices. ## C. Exhaustive axiom audit — every declaration, not just the headlines Generated `#print axioms` mechanically for **all 139 public declarations** (private helpers are covered transitively through the public proof terms): - **134 declarations**: exactly `[propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound]` — including `lambda_pos_finite_height_verified`, both margin evaluations, all of tier (i), and every numeric bound lemma. - **5 declarations**: the standard three + `sorryAx` — exactly the intended skeletons. - **Nothing else anywhere.** Output archived in the repo (`audit-session013-axioms.txt` + the `PrintAxiomsAll.lean` generator, so anyone can reproduce it). ## D. Statement-to-paper correspondence Verified line by line that `lambda_pos_finite_height_verified` **is** Paper A's Theorem R-004: same bound `(3×10¹²−1)²`, same λ_n (zero-side sum with multiplicity), and exactly the three named hypotheses the paper declares (Platt–Trudgian `RHUpTo`, `LiVerifiedUpTo 5×10⁵`, `SfBoundProp`). Full mapping table in D-063 §D. ## E. Inherited library re-verified LIVE All zeta-23-lean comparator scripts re-run: **27 main + 16 amendment statements, verbatim match with AUDIT.md**; no `sorryAx` anywhere in the comparators. --- **Verdict: the package is submission-ready.** Clean-room build green, no hidden axioms, no undocumented sorries, statements match the paper exactly. The audit trail is committed and reproducible.
raw content_json (database row)
[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"There's a `research/paper/submit/instructions.txt` file, empty (0 bytes), created 13:57 today (Aug 20). I didn't create it. The user probably created it — perhaps as a placeholder for submission instructions, or accidentally. It's empty. I'll just mention it in my report and leave it alone (not mine to delete; it's empty and harmless). Actually — given the user asked for submission info, maybe they made the folder intending to collect submission materials. I could offer to move cover-letter.md and referee-list.md into it. But leave decisions to them; just flag it.\n\nNow give the final audit report summary to the user.","signature":""},{"type":"text","text":"That's an empty file (0 bytes) created today at 13:57 — presumably your placeholder for submission materials. I've left it untouched; say the word if you'd like the cover letter and referee list moved there.\n\n---\n\n# Audit complete — everything checks out. Full report (filed as D-063, committed `e5e7ed1`):\n\n## A. Source sweep\n- **`sorry` tactics: exactly 5** — the intended skeletons only (1 Suzuki factorization + 4 valley statements, all in Paper B's territory). Every other \"sorry\" hit is a comment.\n- **Zero forbidden constructs**: no `admit`, no `axiom` declarations, no `native_decide`, no `unsafe`, no `@[implemented_by]`.\n- One `set_option maxHeartbeats 800000` (elaborator budget only — cannot weaken kernel checking).\n\n## B. Clean-room rebuild\nDeleted `.lake/build` entirely and rebuilt from scratch: **8707 jobs, green** (LiSkeleton 46 s, LiBasePoints 22 s, root 15 s). Only warnings: the 5 intended sorry notices.\n\n## C. Exhaustive axiom audit — every declaration, not just the headlines\nGenerated `#print axioms` mechanically for **all 139 public declarations** (private helpers are covered transitively through the public proof terms):\n- **134 declarations**: exactly `[propext, Classical.choice, Quot.sound]` — including `lambda_pos_finite_height_verified`, both margin evaluations, all of tier (i), and every numeric bound lemma.\n- **5 declarations**: the standard three + `sorryAx` — exactly the intended skeletons.\n- **Nothing else anywhere.** Output archived in the repo (`audit-session013-axioms.txt` + the `PrintAxiomsAll.lean` generator, so anyone can reproduce it).\n\n## D. Statement-to-paper correspondence\nVerified line by line that `lambda_pos_finite_height_verified` **is** Paper A's Theorem R-004: same bound `(3×10¹²−1)²`, same λ_n (zero-side sum with multiplicity), and exactly the three named hypotheses the paper declares (Platt–Trudgian `RHUpTo`, `LiVerifiedUpTo 5×10⁵`, `SfBoundProp`). Full mapping table in D-063 §D.\n\n## E. Inherited library re-verified LIVE\nAll zeta-23-lean comparator scripts re-run: **27 main + 16 amendment statements, verbatim match with AUDIT.md**; no `sorryAx` anywhere in the comparators.\n\n---\n\n**Verdict: the package is submission-ready.** Clean-room build green, no hidden axioms, no undocumented sorries, statements match the paper exactly. The audit trail is committed and reproducible."}]