← Session 24 — ii′-2…4: swaps, (4.10) design, contour + website roadmap fixes
thinking (3564 chars)
`Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt (hf : analyticOrderAt f z₀ ≠ ⊤) : ↑(analyticOrderNatAt f z₀) = analyticOrderAt f z₀` (with the cast implicit in the display — it's `((analyticOrderNatAt f z₀ : ℕ) : ℕ∞) = analyticOrderAt f z₀`).
So the final chain for the order invariance:
```lean
have hF_top : analyticOrderAt (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) w₀ ≠ ⊤ := by
rw [horder]
exact ENat.natCast_ne_top _ -- hmm — with horder : analyticOrderAt F w₀ = ↑(m): rw makes goal ↑(m) ≠ ⊤: ENat.natCast_ne_top : (↑n : ℕ∞) ≠ ⊤? or (n : ℕ∞) ≠ ⊤... `ENat.natCast_ne_top (n : ℕ) : (↑n : ℕ∞) ≠ ⊤`? hmm — the form: (↑(m) : ℕ∞) ≠ ⊤: ENat.natCast_ne_top _ ✓ or `by simp`.
have h1 := Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt hF_top -- ↑(analyticOrderNatAt F w₀) = analyticOrderAt F w₀
have h2 := Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt (zeta_order_ne_top_of_ne hz₀ne) -- ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀
rw [← Nat.cast_inj (R := ℕ∞)] -- goal ↑(mF) = ↑(mζ)
rw [h1, h2, horder] -- goal: ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀?? — no: after h1: analyticOrderAt F w₀ = ...; h2: RHS ↑(mζ) → analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: goal analyticOrderAt F w₀ = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: horder : analyticOrderAt F w₀ = ↑(mζ): rw [horder]: goal ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: close via h2.symm: exact h2.symm
```
So: rw [h1, h2, horder]; exact h2.symm — hmm after rw [h1, h2, horder]: the goal becomes ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀?? wait — h2 : ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ — rw [h2] rewrites ↑(mζ) → analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ in the goal — the goal at that point: analyticOrderAt F w₀ = ↑(mζ) — rw [h2] targets ↑(mζ)?? — the ↑(mζ) appears on the RHS ✓ becomes analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: goal analyticOrderAt F w₀ = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: then rw [horder]: LHS → ↑(mζ): goal ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ — hmm — then `exact h2.symm`? h2.symm : analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ = ↑(mζ) — goal is ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: that's h2 ✓ exact h2. Wait I flipped: goal after rw [horder]: ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ and h2 : ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ — EXACT MATCH: exact h2. Hmm but then the earlier rw [h2] already consumed it... — after `rw [h1, h2, horder]`: rw [h1]: ↑(mF) → analyticOrderAt F w₀; rw [h2]: ↑(mζ) → analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: goal becomes analyticOrderAt F w₀ = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀; rw [horder]: analyticOrderAt F w₀ → ↑(mζ): goal ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ — which is h2 — but h2 was already used in the rw chain... it's still available as a hypothesis ✓ `exact h2`. Hmm wait — does rw [h2] at that point work? After rw [h1]: goal: analyticOrderAt F w₀ = ↑(mζ): rw [h2] rewrites ↑(mζ) → analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ ✓: goal analyticOrderAt F w₀ = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: then horder : analyticOrderAt F w₀ = ↑(mζ) — rw [horder] rewrites the analyticOrderAt F w₀ → ↑(mζ): goal ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ = h2 ✓ exact h2. OK.
Hmm actually — simpler: skip the natCast_inj dance: the goal analyticOrderNatAt F w₀ = analyticOrderNatAt ζ z₀ (an ℕ equality):
```lean
have : (analyticOrderNatAt (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5/2:ℂ)*w)) w₀ : ℕ∞) = analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀ := by
rw [Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt hF_top, Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt (zeta_order_ne_top_of_ne hz₀ne), horder]
exact ENat.natCast_inj.mp this -- or Nat.cast_inj.mp
```
`Nat.cast_inj (R := ℕ∞)`? — (a : ℕ) = (b : ℕ) from (↑a : ℕ∞) = ↑b: `Nat.cast_inj.mp`? WithTop.coe_inj? ENat natCast inj: `ENat.natCast_inj`? or `Nat.cast_inj (R := ℕ∞)`: (↑a : ℕ∞) = ↑b ↔ a = b ✓ `Nat.cast_inj`. So exact Nat.cast_inj.mp this. OK.
Let me apply the three fixes (h3'.trans chain, the final order chain, and div_eq_zero's resolve_right + mem form).
Applying the three fixes.
tool: Edit
input
{
"replace_all": false,
"file_path": "D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiDisc.lean",
"old_string": " have h3' := h3.comp_tendsto haffT\n -- h3' : (fun z => (z \u2212 z\u2080)^m \u2022 h' z) \u2218 aff =\u1da0 \u03b6 \u2218 aff; massage the form\n have hF : (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w)) =\u1da0[\ud835\udcdd w\u2080]\n fun w => (w - w\u2080) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z\u2080 \u2022\n (((5 / 2 : \u2102) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z\u2080) *\n h' (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w)) := by\n apply h3'.congr'\n filter_upwards with w\n simp only [Function.comp_apply]\n rw [show discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w - z\u2080 = (5 / 2 : \u2102) * (w - w\u2080) by rw [hz\u2080]; ring]\n rw [mul_pow, smul_eq_mul, smul_eq_mul]\n ring\n have hcof : AnalyticAt \u2102 (fun w => ((5 / 2 : \u2102) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z\u2080) *\n h' (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w)) w\u2080 :=\n (analyticAt_const.mul (h1.comp_of_eq haff rfl)) -- hmm h1 is AnalyticAt h' z\u2080\n have hcof_ne : ((5 / 2 : \u2102) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z\u2080) * h' z\u2080 \u2260 0 :=\n mul_ne_zero (pow_ne_zero _ (by norm_num)) h2\n have hF_an : AnalyticAt \u2102 (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w)) w\u2080 :=\n analyticAt_riemannZeta_of_ne_one hz\u2080ne |>.comp_of_eq haff rfl\n have horder : analyticOrderAt (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w)) w\u2080\n = (analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z\u2080 : \u2115\u221e) :=\n (hF_an.analyticOrderAt_eq_natCast).mpr \u27e8_, hcof, hcof_ne, hF\u27e9\n rw [\u2190 Nat.cast_inj (R := \u2115\u221e), Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt\n (zeta_order_ne_top_of_ne hz\u2080ne), horder]",
"new_string": " have h3' := h3.comp_tendsto haffT\n -- h3' : \u03b6 \u2218 aff =\u1da0 series \u2218 aff; massage the form\n have hpt : \u2200 w : \u2102,\n ((fun z => (z - z\u2080) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z\u2080 \u2022 h' z) \u2218\n fun w => discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w) w\n = (w - w\u2080) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z\u2080 \u2022\n (((5 / 2 : \u2102) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z\u2080) *\n h' (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w)) := by\n intro w\n simp only [Function.comp_apply]\n rw [show discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w - z\u2080 = (5 / 2 : \u2102) * (w - w\u2080) by rw [hz\u2080]; ring]\n rw [mul_pow, smul_eq_mul, smul_eq_mul]\n ring\n have hF : (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w)) =\u1da0[\ud835\udcdd w\u2080]\n fun w => (w - w\u2080) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z\u2080 \u2022\n (((5 / 2 : \u2102) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z\u2080) *\n h' (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w)) :=\n h3'.trans (Filter.Eventually.of_forall hpt)\n have hcof : AnalyticAt \u2102 (fun w => ((5 / 2 : \u2102) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z\u2080) *\n h' (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w)) w\u2080 :=\n analyticAt_const.mul (h1.comp_of_eq haff rfl)\n have hcof_ne : ((5 / 2 : \u2102) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z\u2080) * h' z\u2080 \u2260 0 :=\n mul_ne_zero (pow_ne_zero _ (by norm_num)) h2\n have hF_an : AnalyticAt \u2102 (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w)) w\u2080 :=\n analyticAt_riemannZeta_of_ne_one hz\u2080ne |>.comp_of_eq haff rfl\n have horder : analyticOrderAt (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w)) w\u2080\n = (analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z\u2080 : \u2115\u221e) :=\n (hF_an.analyticOrderAt_eq_natCast).mpr \u27e8_, hcof, hcof_ne, hF\u27e9\n have hF_top : analyticOrderAt (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w)) w\u2080\n \u2260 \u22a4 := by\n rw [horder]\n exact ENat.natCast_ne_top _\n have h1c := Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt hF_top\n have h2c := Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt (zeta_order_ne_top_of_ne hz\u2080ne)\n have hcast : ((analyticOrderNatAt (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : \u2102) * w)) w\u2080\n : \u2115) : \u2115\u221e) = ((analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z\u2080 : \u2115) : \u2115\u221e) := by\n rw [h1c, h2c, horder]\n exact Nat.cast_inj.mp hcast"
}
raw content_json (database row)
[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"`Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt (hf : analyticOrderAt f z₀ ≠ ⊤) : ↑(analyticOrderNatAt f z₀) = analyticOrderAt f z₀` (with the cast implicit in the display — it's `((analyticOrderNatAt f z₀ : ℕ) : ℕ∞) = analyticOrderAt f z₀`).\n\nSo the final chain for the order invariance:\n```lean\n have hF_top : analyticOrderAt (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) w₀ ≠ ⊤ := by\n rw [horder]\n exact ENat.natCast_ne_top _ -- hmm — with horder : analyticOrderAt F w₀ = ↑(m): rw makes goal ↑(m) ≠ ⊤: ENat.natCast_ne_top : (↑n : ℕ∞) ≠ ⊤? or (n : ℕ∞) ≠ ⊤... `ENat.natCast_ne_top (n : ℕ) : (↑n : ℕ∞) ≠ ⊤`? hmm — the form: (↑(m) : ℕ∞) ≠ ⊤: ENat.natCast_ne_top _ ✓ or `by simp`.\n have h1 := Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt hF_top -- ↑(analyticOrderNatAt F w₀) = analyticOrderAt F w₀\n have h2 := Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt (zeta_order_ne_top_of_ne hz₀ne) -- ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀\n rw [← Nat.cast_inj (R := ℕ∞)] -- goal ↑(mF) = ↑(mζ)\n rw [h1, h2, horder] -- goal: ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀?? — no: after h1: analyticOrderAt F w₀ = ...; h2: RHS ↑(mζ) → analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: goal analyticOrderAt F w₀ = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: horder : analyticOrderAt F w₀ = ↑(mζ): rw [horder]: goal ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: close via h2.symm: exact h2.symm\n```\nSo: rw [h1, h2, horder]; exact h2.symm — hmm after rw [h1, h2, horder]: the goal becomes ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀?? wait — h2 : ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ — rw [h2] rewrites ↑(mζ) → analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ in the goal — the goal at that point: analyticOrderAt F w₀ = ↑(mζ) — rw [h2] targets ↑(mζ)?? — the ↑(mζ) appears on the RHS ✓ becomes analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: goal analyticOrderAt F w₀ = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: then rw [horder]: LHS → ↑(mζ): goal ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ — hmm — then `exact h2.symm`? h2.symm : analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ = ↑(mζ) — goal is ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: that's h2 ✓ exact h2. Wait I flipped: goal after rw [horder]: ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ and h2 : ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ — EXACT MATCH: exact h2. Hmm but then the earlier rw [h2] already consumed it... — after `rw [h1, h2, horder]`: rw [h1]: ↑(mF) → analyticOrderAt F w₀; rw [h2]: ↑(mζ) → analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: goal becomes analyticOrderAt F w₀ = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀; rw [horder]: analyticOrderAt F w₀ → ↑(mζ): goal ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ — which is h2 — but h2 was already used in the rw chain... it's still available as a hypothesis ✓ `exact h2`. Hmm wait — does rw [h2] at that point work? After rw [h1]: goal: analyticOrderAt F w₀ = ↑(mζ): rw [h2] rewrites ↑(mζ) → analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ ✓: goal analyticOrderAt F w₀ = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀: then horder : analyticOrderAt F w₀ = ↑(mζ) — rw [horder] rewrites the analyticOrderAt F w₀ → ↑(mζ): goal ↑(mζ) = analyticOrderAt ζ z₀ = h2 ✓ exact h2. OK.\n\nHmm actually — simpler: skip the natCast_inj dance: the goal analyticOrderNatAt F w₀ = analyticOrderNatAt ζ z₀ (an ℕ equality): \n```lean\n have : (analyticOrderNatAt (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5/2:ℂ)*w)) w₀ : ℕ∞) = analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀ := by\n rw [Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt hF_top, Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt (zeta_order_ne_top_of_ne hz₀ne), horder]\n exact ENat.natCast_inj.mp this -- or Nat.cast_inj.mp\n```\n`Nat.cast_inj (R := ℕ∞)`? — (a : ℕ) = (b : ℕ) from (↑a : ℕ∞) = ↑b: `Nat.cast_inj.mp`? WithTop.coe_inj? ENat natCast inj: `ENat.natCast_inj`? or `Nat.cast_inj (R := ℕ∞)`: (↑a : ℕ∞) = ↑b ↔ a = b ✓ `Nat.cast_inj`. So exact Nat.cast_inj.mp this. OK.\n\nLet me apply the three fixes (h3'.trans chain, the final order chain, and div_eq_zero's resolve_right + mem form).","signature":""},{"type":"text","text":"Applying the three fixes."},{"type":"tool_use","id":"Edit_366","name":"Edit","input":{"replace_all":false,"file_path":"D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiDisc.lean","old_string":" have h3' := h3.comp_tendsto haffT\n -- h3' : (fun z => (z − z₀)^m • h' z) ∘ aff =ᶠ ζ ∘ aff; massage the form\n have hF : (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) =ᶠ[𝓝 w₀]\n fun w => (w - w₀) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀ •\n (((5 / 2 : ℂ) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀) *\n h' (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) := by\n apply h3'.congr'\n filter_upwards with w\n simp only [Function.comp_apply]\n rw [show discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w - z₀ = (5 / 2 : ℂ) * (w - w₀) by rw [hz₀]; ring]\n rw [mul_pow, smul_eq_mul, smul_eq_mul]\n ring\n have hcof : AnalyticAt ℂ (fun w => ((5 / 2 : ℂ) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀) *\n h' (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) w₀ :=\n (analyticAt_const.mul (h1.comp_of_eq haff rfl)) -- hmm h1 is AnalyticAt h' z₀\n have hcof_ne : ((5 / 2 : ℂ) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀) * h' z₀ ≠ 0 :=\n mul_ne_zero (pow_ne_zero _ (by norm_num)) h2\n have hF_an : AnalyticAt ℂ (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) w₀ :=\n analyticAt_riemannZeta_of_ne_one hz₀ne |>.comp_of_eq haff rfl\n have horder : analyticOrderAt (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) w₀\n = (analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀ : ℕ∞) :=\n (hF_an.analyticOrderAt_eq_natCast).mpr ⟨_, hcof, hcof_ne, hF⟩\n rw [← Nat.cast_inj (R := ℕ∞), Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt\n (zeta_order_ne_top_of_ne hz₀ne), horder]","new_string":" have h3' := h3.comp_tendsto haffT\n -- h3' : ζ ∘ aff =ᶠ series ∘ aff; massage the form\n have hpt : ∀ w : ℂ,\n ((fun z => (z - z₀) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀ • h' z) ∘\n fun w => discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w) w\n = (w - w₀) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀ •\n (((5 / 2 : ℂ) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀) *\n h' (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) := by\n intro w\n simp only [Function.comp_apply]\n rw [show discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w - z₀ = (5 / 2 : ℂ) * (w - w₀) by rw [hz₀]; ring]\n rw [mul_pow, smul_eq_mul, smul_eq_mul]\n ring\n have hF : (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) =ᶠ[𝓝 w₀]\n fun w => (w - w₀) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀ •\n (((5 / 2 : ℂ) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀) *\n h' (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) :=\n h3'.trans (Filter.Eventually.of_forall hpt)\n have hcof : AnalyticAt ℂ (fun w => ((5 / 2 : ℂ) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀) *\n h' (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) w₀ :=\n analyticAt_const.mul (h1.comp_of_eq haff rfl)\n have hcof_ne : ((5 / 2 : ℂ) ^ analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀) * h' z₀ ≠ 0 :=\n mul_ne_zero (pow_ne_zero _ (by norm_num)) h2\n have hF_an : AnalyticAt ℂ (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) w₀ :=\n analyticAt_riemannZeta_of_ne_one hz₀ne |>.comp_of_eq haff rfl\n have horder : analyticOrderAt (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) w₀\n = (analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀ : ℕ∞) :=\n (hF_an.analyticOrderAt_eq_natCast).mpr ⟨_, hcof, hcof_ne, hF⟩\n have hF_top : analyticOrderAt (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) w₀\n ≠ ⊤ := by\n rw [horder]\n exact ENat.natCast_ne_top _\n have h1c := Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt hF_top\n have h2c := Nat.cast_analyticOrderNatAt (zeta_order_ne_top_of_ne hz₀ne)\n have hcast : ((analyticOrderNatAt (fun w => riemannZeta (discCenter t + (5 / 2 : ℂ) * w)) w₀\n : ℕ) : ℕ∞) = ((analyticOrderNatAt riemannZeta z₀ : ℕ) : ℕ∞) := by\n rw [h1c, h2c, horder]\n exact Nat.cast_inj.mp hcast"},"extra_content":null}]