← Session 29 — ii′-5e-v: circle bound (far-tail + series bounds)
thinking (2744 chars)
Several errors:
1. `cpow_ne_zero` unknown — the name is `Complex.cpow_ne_zero`? Since `open Complex` is active, `cpow_ne_zero` should resolve... it's not there. Check the name: maybe `Complex.cpow_ne_zero` doesn't exist; alternatives: `Complex.cpow_ne_zero_iff` or prove directly: (π:ℂ)^(−s₀/2) = exp(log π·(−s₀/2)) ≠ 0 (exp_ne_zero via cpow_def_of_ne_zero). Let me grep.
2. `logDeriv_mul` signature mismatch — I called `logDeriv_mul _ hne1 hne2 h1 h2` and Lean parsed `logDeriv_mul (-s₀/2) hne1 ?m h1` — the argument order: `logDeriv_mul {f g} (x : 𝕜) (hf : f x ≠ 0) (hg : g x ≠ 0) (hdf) (hdg)` — my `_` for x got unified with `−s₀/2`?? The error shows `logDeriv_mul (-s₀ / 2) hne1 ?m.226 h1` with h1 expected at the hdg slot of type `DifferentiableAt ℂ (HPow.hPow ↑Real.pi) (-s₀ / 2)` — that's `DifferentiableAt ℂ (fun z => c^z)?? no: (HPow.hPow ↑Real.pi) applied to (−s₀/2) — that's g x where g := HPow.hPow π as a function of z... The issue: my f,g are implicit and Lean couldn't infer them properly — f should be `fun z => (π:ℂ)^(-z/2)` and g := fun z => Gamma (z/2): the mismatch shows Lean took g := (HPow.hPow π) (the standalone power) — because h1's type mentions `↑Real.pi ^ (-z / 2)` — elaborator unified f z := π^(−z/2) with f := HPow.hPow π ∘ (−·/2)?? The hg slot expected `DifferentiableAt ℂ (HPow.hPow ↑Real.pi) (-s₀/2)` — wait that's `DifferentiableAt ℂ (HPow.hPow ↑Real.pi) (-s₀/2)` — DifferentiableAt of the FUNCTION (HPow.hPow π) at the POINT (−s₀/2) — so Lean unified g := HPow.hPow ↑Real.pi (the exponentiation function with base π) and the point as... this is the f/g implicit unification mess. Fix: pin f and g explicitly:
`rw [logDeriv_mul (f := fun z : ℂ => (Real.pi : ℂ) ^ (-z / 2)) (g := fun z : ℂ => Complex.Gamma (z / 2)) _ hne1 hne2 h1 h2]`
Wait — logDeriv_mul's statement: `logDeriv (fun z => f z * g z) x = logDeriv f x + logDeriv g x` — the LHS after my `rw [hdef]` is `logDeriv (fun z => ↑Real.pi ^ (-z / 2) * Gamma (z / 2)) s₀` — with f,g pinned the LHS unifies ✓.
3. `nearZeros`/`mem_nearZeros` unknown — they're in LiDisc.lean — is LiDisc imported? LiCircleBound imports NguyenRH1.LiFEntire, LiGapCircles, Zeta23.RvM.LocalCount. LiDisc is imported by... LiFEntire imports LiSides etc. Does anything import LiDisc/LiReflect? LiReflect imports LiDisc probably; LiFEntire might not reach them. Add `import NguyenRH1.LiDisc` (and LiReflect + LiDigammaLeft for later parts) to LiCircleBound's imports. Since those files root-import each other: LiReflect imports LiDisc (5d builds on 5c); LiDigammaLeft imports... 5e-ii. Let me just add all three: LiDisc, LiReflect, LiDigammaLeft.
4. The `⊢ logDeriv ... = ...` unsolved at 2906 — the rw [logDeriv_mul...] failed so the goal remained. Fixed by #2's pin.
Missing imports (nearZeros lives in LiDisc) + the `logDeriv_mul` f/g pinning + the cpow-nonzero name.
tool: Bash
input
{
"command": "cd \"D:/Python/Quantum/research/lean/NguyenRH1\" && grep -rn \"cpow_ne_zero\" ../../../zeta-23-lean/.lake/packages/mathlib/Mathlib/Analysis/SpecialFunctions/Pow/Complex.lean 2>/dev/null | head -3; head -30 NguyenRH1/LiCircleBound.lean | grep -n \"import\"",
"description": "Find cpow_ne_zero + current imports"
}
raw content_json (database row)
[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"Several errors:\n\n1. `cpow_ne_zero` unknown — the name is `Complex.cpow_ne_zero`? Since `open Complex` is active, `cpow_ne_zero` should resolve... it's not there. Check the name: maybe `Complex.cpow_ne_zero` doesn't exist; alternatives: `Complex.cpow_ne_zero_iff` or prove directly: (π:ℂ)^(−s₀/2) = exp(log π·(−s₀/2)) ≠ 0 (exp_ne_zero via cpow_def_of_ne_zero). Let me grep.\n\n2. `logDeriv_mul` signature mismatch — I called `logDeriv_mul _ hne1 hne2 h1 h2` and Lean parsed `logDeriv_mul (-s₀/2) hne1 ?m h1` — the argument order: `logDeriv_mul {f g} (x : 𝕜) (hf : f x ≠ 0) (hg : g x ≠ 0) (hdf) (hdg)` — my `_` for x got unified with `−s₀/2`?? The error shows `logDeriv_mul (-s₀ / 2) hne1 ?m.226 h1` with h1 expected at the hdg slot of type `DifferentiableAt ℂ (HPow.hPow ↑Real.pi) (-s₀ / 2)` — that's `DifferentiableAt ℂ (fun z => c^z)?? no: (HPow.hPow ↑Real.pi) applied to (−s₀/2) — that's g x where g := HPow.hPow π as a function of z... The issue: my f,g are implicit and Lean couldn't infer them properly — f should be `fun z => (π:ℂ)^(-z/2)` and g := fun z => Gamma (z/2): the mismatch shows Lean took g := (HPow.hPow π) (the standalone power) — because h1's type mentions `↑Real.pi ^ (-z / 2)` — elaborator unified f z := π^(−z/2) with f := HPow.hPow π ∘ (−·/2)?? The hg slot expected `DifferentiableAt ℂ (HPow.hPow ↑Real.pi) (-s₀/2)` — wait that's `DifferentiableAt ℂ (HPow.hPow ↑Real.pi) (-s₀/2)` — DifferentiableAt of the FUNCTION (HPow.hPow π) at the POINT (−s₀/2) — so Lean unified g := HPow.hPow ↑Real.pi (the exponentiation function with base π) and the point as... this is the f/g implicit unification mess. Fix: pin f and g explicitly:\n `rw [logDeriv_mul (f := fun z : ℂ => (Real.pi : ℂ) ^ (-z / 2)) (g := fun z : ℂ => Complex.Gamma (z / 2)) _ hne1 hne2 h1 h2]`\n Wait — logDeriv_mul's statement: `logDeriv (fun z => f z * g z) x = logDeriv f x + logDeriv g x` — the LHS after my `rw [hdef]` is `logDeriv (fun z => ↑Real.pi ^ (-z / 2) * Gamma (z / 2)) s₀` — with f,g pinned the LHS unifies ✓.\n\n3. `nearZeros`/`mem_nearZeros` unknown — they're in LiDisc.lean — is LiDisc imported? LiCircleBound imports NguyenRH1.LiFEntire, LiGapCircles, Zeta23.RvM.LocalCount. LiDisc is imported by... LiFEntire imports LiSides etc. Does anything import LiDisc/LiReflect? LiReflect imports LiDisc probably; LiFEntire might not reach them. Add `import NguyenRH1.LiDisc` (and LiReflect + LiDigammaLeft for later parts) to LiCircleBound's imports. Since those files root-import each other: LiReflect imports LiDisc (5d builds on 5c); LiDigammaLeft imports... 5e-ii. Let me just add all three: LiDisc, LiReflect, LiDigammaLeft.\n\n4. The `⊢ logDeriv ... = ...` unsolved at 2906 — the rw [logDeriv_mul...] failed so the goal remained. Fixed by #2's pin.","signature":""},{"type":"text","text":"Missing imports (nearZeros lives in LiDisc) + the `logDeriv_mul` f/g pinning + the cpow-nonzero name."},{"type":"tool_use","id":"Bash_166","name":"Bash","input":{"command":"cd \"D:/Python/Quantum/research/lean/NguyenRH1\" && grep -rn \"cpow_ne_zero\" ../../../zeta-23-lean/.lake/packages/mathlib/Mathlib/Analysis/SpecialFunctions/Pow/Complex.lean 2>/dev/null | head -3; head -30 NguyenRH1/LiCircleBound.lean | grep -n \"import\"","description":"Find cpow_ne_zero + current imports"},"extra_content":null}]