Current task: —

← Session 29 — ii′-5e-v: circle bound (far-tail + series bounds)

#1660 assistant 2026-08-24 04:38:39.007 UTC · 985→1593 tok open ⤢
thinking (2749 chars)
Progress. New errors: 1. Line 3599: `rw [Complex.neg_im, Complex.natCast_im]` leaves `-0 = 0` — the goal after neg_im: `-(↑m).im = 0` → natCast_im: `(↑m).im = 0`?? the rw produced goal `−0 = 0` (after natCast_im rewrote (↑m).im to 0): remaining `−0 = 0` — close by `neg_zero` simp or norm_num: change h3's proof to `simp` — `(-(m : ℂ)).im = 0` by simp (neg_im, natCast_im, neg_zero). Replace with `by simp`. 2. Line 3623 (hG1's hre): `h3` has type `(1 - s.re) / 2 = -↑m` but expected `((1 - s) / 2).re = -↑m` — in hG1's hre block: ``` have hre : ((1 - s) / 2).re = -(m : ℝ) := by have h3 := congrArg Complex.re h2 rw [Complex.neg_re, Complex.natCast_re] at h3 have h4 : ((1 - s) / 2).re = (1 - s.re) / 2 := by simp [Complex.div_re] rw [h4] at h3 exact h3 ``` h3 after congrArg Complex.re h2 : ((1−s)/2).re = (−↑m).re — then rw [neg_re, natCast_re] at h3: h3 : ((1−s)/2).re = −(↑m).re?? wait — the RHS: (−↑m).re → neg_re: −((↑m).re) → natCast_re: −↑m ✓ so h3 : ((1−s)/2).re = −↑m ✓. Then rw [h4] at h3 — h4 : ((1−s)/2).re = (1−s.re)/2 — rewrites the LHS of h3: h3 : (1−s.re)/2 = −↑m — then `exact h3` — but hre's GOAL is `((1 - s) / 2).re = -(m : ℝ)` — h3 has the rewritten form (1−s.re)/2 — NOT the goal form! The rw [h4] at h3 changed h3's LHS away from the goal form. Fix: don't rw at h3 — instead convert the GOAL: ``` have hre : ((1 - s) / 2).re = -(m : ℝ) := by have h4 : ((1 - s) / 2).re = (1 - s.re) / 2 := by simp [Complex.div_re] rw [h4] have h3 := congrArg Complex.re h2 rw [Complex.neg_re, Complex.natCast_re] at h3 rw [h4] at h3 exact h3 ``` hmm — but the error shows h4 = `simp [Complex.div_re]` produced `(1 - s.re) / 2 = ...`?? The error: `h3 has type (1 - s.re) / 2 = -↑m but expected ((1 - s) / 2).re = -↑m` — so after my rw [h4] at h3, h3 became (1−s.re)/2-form, and exact h3 against goal ((1−s)/2).re-form fails. Restructure per above: rw [h4] at the GOAL first, then exact h3 (already in (1−s.re)/2-form). Wait — actually hold on: `simp [Complex.div_re]` for h4 : ((1 − s) / 2).re = (1 − s.re) / 2 — did simp prove it? If simp produced something odd... the error message is about the EXACT h3 mismatch — so h4 exists. Restructure: rw [h4] at the goal THEN exact h3. Hmm — but actually ((1−s)/2).re vs (1−s.re)/2 — also relevant for hpos etc. Let me fix hG1's hre block by reordering. 3. Line 3636 "No goals" — cascade. 4. Line 3666 — let me see after fixing. Also the 242 n-unused warning (dirichletC2_nonneg's `fun n => norm_nonneg _` — the n is unused: change to `fun _ => norm_nonneg _`... wait the warning is at 242:19 — dirichletC2_nonneg's lambda binder — hmm `fun n => norm_nonneg _` — n used as norm's arg? `norm_nonneg _` — the _ is inferred — n unused ✓ change to `fun _ => norm_nonneg _`.
Fixing h3's `-0 = 0` remainder, hG1's hre ordering, and the unused-binder warning.
tool: Bash
input
{
  "command": "cd \"D:/Python/Quantum/research/lean/NguyenRH1\" && python - << 'PYEOF'\np = 'NguyenRH1/LiCircleBound.lean'\nsrc = open(p, encoding='utf-8').read()\nsrc = src.replace('tsum_nonneg (fun n => norm_nonneg _)', 'tsum_nonneg (fun _ => norm_nonneg _)')\nsrc = src.replace('''          have h3 : (-(m : \u2102)).im = 0 := by\n            rw [Complex.neg_im, Complex.natCast_im]''', '''          have h3 : (-(m : \u2102)).im = 0 := by simp''')\n# hG1's hre block: reorder\nsrc = src.replace('''        have hre : ((1 - s) / 2).re = -(m : \u211d) := by\n          have h3 := congrArg Complex.re h2\n          rw [Complex.neg_re, Complex.natCast_re] at h3\n          have h4 : ((1 - s) / 2).re = (1 - s.re) / 2 := by simp [Complex.div_re]\n          rw [h4] at h3\n          exact h3''', '''        have hre : ((1 - s) / 2).re = -(m : \u211d) := by\n          have h4 : ((1 - s) / 2).re = (1 - s.re) / 2 := by simp [Complex.div_re]\n          rw [h4]\n          have h3 := congrArg Complex.re h2\n          rw [Complex.neg_re, Complex.natCast_re] at h3\n          rw [h4] at h3\n          exact h3''')\nopen(p, 'w', encoding='utf-8').write(src)\nPYEOF\nexport PATH=\"$HOME/.elan/bin:$PATH\" && lake env lean NguyenRH1/LiCircleBound.lean 2>&1 | head -40",
  "description": "Fix h3, hre ordering; recompile",
  "timeout": 300000
}
raw content_json (database row)
[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"Progress. New errors:\n\n1. Line 3599: `rw [Complex.neg_im, Complex.natCast_im]` leaves `-0 = 0` — the goal after neg_im: `-(↑m).im = 0` → natCast_im: `(↑m).im = 0`?? the rw produced goal `−0 = 0` (after natCast_im rewrote (↑m).im to 0): remaining `−0 = 0` — close by `neg_zero` simp or norm_num: change h3's proof to `simp` — `(-(m : ℂ)).im = 0` by simp (neg_im, natCast_im, neg_zero). Replace with `by simp`.\n\n2. Line 3623 (hG1's hre): `h3` has type `(1 - s.re) / 2 = -↑m` but expected `((1 - s) / 2).re = -↑m` — in hG1's hre block:\n```\nhave hre : ((1 - s) / 2).re = -(m : ℝ) := by\n  have h3 := congrArg Complex.re h2\n  rw [Complex.neg_re, Complex.natCast_re] at h3\n  have h4 : ((1 - s) / 2).re = (1 - s.re) / 2 := by simp [Complex.div_re]\n  rw [h4] at h3\n  exact h3\n```\nh3 after congrArg Complex.re h2 : ((1−s)/2).re = (−↑m).re — then rw [neg_re, natCast_re] at h3: h3 : ((1−s)/2).re = −(↑m).re?? wait — the RHS: (−↑m).re → neg_re: −((↑m).re) → natCast_re: −↑m ✓ so h3 : ((1−s)/2).re = −↑m ✓. Then rw [h4] at h3 — h4 : ((1−s)/2).re = (1−s.re)/2 — rewrites the LHS of h3: h3 : (1−s.re)/2 = −↑m — then `exact h3` — but hre's GOAL is `((1 - s) / 2).re = -(m : ℝ)` — h3 has the rewritten form (1−s.re)/2 — NOT the goal form! The rw [h4] at h3 changed h3's LHS away from the goal form. Fix: don't rw at h3 — instead convert the GOAL: \n```\nhave hre : ((1 - s) / 2).re = -(m : ℝ) := by\n  have h4 : ((1 - s) / 2).re = (1 - s.re) / 2 := by simp [Complex.div_re]\n  rw [h4]\n  have h3 := congrArg Complex.re h2\n  rw [Complex.neg_re, Complex.natCast_re] at h3\n  rw [h4] at h3\n  exact h3\n```\nhmm — but the error shows h4 = `simp [Complex.div_re]` produced `(1 - s.re) / 2 = ...`?? The error: `h3 has type (1 - s.re) / 2 = -↑m but expected ((1 - s) / 2).re = -↑m` — so after my rw [h4] at h3, h3 became (1−s.re)/2-form, and exact h3 against goal ((1−s)/2).re-form fails. Restructure per above: rw [h4] at the GOAL first, then exact h3 (already in (1−s.re)/2-form).\n\nWait — actually hold on: `simp [Complex.div_re]` for h4 : ((1 − s) / 2).re = (1 − s.re) / 2 — did simp prove it? If simp produced something odd... the error message is about the EXACT h3 mismatch — so h4 exists. Restructure: rw [h4] at the goal THEN exact h3.\n\nHmm — but actually ((1−s)/2).re vs (1−s.re)/2 — also relevant for hpos etc. Let me fix hG1's hre block by reordering.\n\n3. Line 3636 \"No goals\" — cascade.\n\n4. Line 3666 — let me see after fixing.\n\nAlso the 242 n-unused warning (dirichletC2_nonneg's `fun n => norm_nonneg _` — the n is unused: change to `fun _ => norm_nonneg _`... wait the warning is at 242:19 — dirichletC2_nonneg's lambda binder — hmm `fun n => norm_nonneg _` — n used as norm's arg? `norm_nonneg _` — the _ is inferred — n unused ✓ change to `fun _ => norm_nonneg _`.","signature":""},{"type":"text","text":"Fixing h3's `-0 = 0` remainder, hG1's hre ordering, and the unused-binder warning."},{"type":"tool_use","id":"Bash_228","name":"Bash","input":{"command":"cd \"D:/Python/Quantum/research/lean/NguyenRH1\" && python - << 'PYEOF'\np = 'NguyenRH1/LiCircleBound.lean'\nsrc = open(p, encoding='utf-8').read()\nsrc = src.replace('tsum_nonneg (fun n => norm_nonneg _)', 'tsum_nonneg (fun _ => norm_nonneg _)')\nsrc = src.replace('''          have h3 : (-(m : ℂ)).im = 0 := by\n            rw [Complex.neg_im, Complex.natCast_im]''', '''          have h3 : (-(m : ℂ)).im = 0 := by simp''')\n# hG1's hre block: reorder\nsrc = src.replace('''        have hre : ((1 - s) / 2).re = -(m : ℝ) := by\n          have h3 := congrArg Complex.re h2\n          rw [Complex.neg_re, Complex.natCast_re] at h3\n          have h4 : ((1 - s) / 2).re = (1 - s.re) / 2 := by simp [Complex.div_re]\n          rw [h4] at h3\n          exact h3''', '''        have hre : ((1 - s) / 2).re = -(m : ℝ) := by\n          have h4 : ((1 - s) / 2).re = (1 - s.re) / 2 := by simp [Complex.div_re]\n          rw [h4]\n          have h3 := congrArg Complex.re h2\n          rw [Complex.neg_re, Complex.natCast_re] at h3\n          rw [h4] at h3\n          exact h3''')\nopen(p, 'w', encoding='utf-8').write(src)\nPYEOF\nexport PATH=\"$HOME/.elan/bin:$PATH\" && lake env lean NguyenRH1/LiCircleBound.lean 2>&1 | head -40","description":"Fix h3, hre ordering; recompile","timeout":300000},"extra_content":null}]