← Session 33 — ii′-3b/3c crux + F-D finding; Lagarias letter package
thinking (2726 chars)
Three errors:
1. **Finset.sum_union_inter named args**: the params are `s₁`/`s₂` (not s/t). Fix: `(s₁ := ...) (s₂ := ...)`. Also f — probably `{f}` implicit — keep `(f := ...)`.
2. **C0hat_mono unknown**: it's in LiGapCircles.lean — LiContour doesn't import LiGapCircles. Options: import it (LiGapCircles imports LiContour — CIRCULAR!). C0hat_mono is in LiGapCircles which imports LiContour (for ZeroCountProp/exists_zero_avoiding_T?) — so LiContour can't import LiGapCircles. Alternative: prove the monotonicity inline (C0hat is monotone in t: derivative-free — log(t+2) and log log(t+2) are monotone — prove directly: Real.log_le_log + Real.log_le_log composition):
```lean
have hmono1 : C0hat a ≤ C0hat (a + 2) := by
unfold C0hat
have h1 : Real.log (a + 2) ≤ Real.log (a + 2 + 2) :=
Real.log_le_log (by positivity) (by linarith)
have h2 : Real.log (Real.log (a + 2)) ≤ Real.log (Real.log (a + 2 + 2)) := by
apply Real.log_le_log (Real.log_pos (by linarith)) h1
linarith
```
Wait — Real.log_le_log signature: Real.log_le_log (hx : 0 < x) (h : x ≤ y) : log x ≤ log y ✓. For h2: Real.log_le_log (show 0 < Real.log (a+2) from Real.log_pos (by linarith : 1 < a+2... a ≥ 3 so a+2 ≥ 5 > e ✓ 1 < a+2 via linarith)) h1 ✓.
Note the C0hat argument shift: C0hat(a+2) unfolds to 0.433·log(a+2+2) + ... — the def C0hat t := 0.433·log(t+2)+...: C0hat (a+2) → log((a+2)+2) = log(a+2+2) ✓.
Also the third error shows h1's bound: C0hat (a − 1 + 1) — the hZC (a−1) gives ≤ C0hat ((a−1)+1) = C0hat a — syntactically `C0hat (a - 1 + 1)` ≠ `C0hat a`! linarith can't see them as equal (they're defeq but linarith works syntactically on atoms). Fix: convert h1's bound: have h1 := hZC (a-1) ... gives ≤ C0hat (a−1+1); rewrite: `rw [show a - 1 + 1 = a from by ring] at h1`? or pass the bound differently: hZC's statement: ≤ C0hat (t + 1) with t := a−1: C0hat ((a−1)+1) — provide a rewritten version:
```lean
have h1 : (∑ ρ ∈ (zeroWindow_finite (a - 1)).toFinset, (zeroMult ρ : ℝ)) ≤ C0hat a := by
have h := hZC (a - 1) (by linarith)
rwa [show a - 1 + 1 = a from by ring] at h
```
And h3 : ≤ C0hat (a+1+1): rewrite to C0hat (a+2): rwa [show a + 1 + 1 = a + 2 from by ring] at h3. Then the final linarith: hsum1 + hsum2 gives Σ_wide ≤ C0hat a + C0hat (a+1) + C0hat (a+2)... wait hsum2's RHS is Σ(a−1) + (Σa + Σ(a+1)) ≤ C0hat a + (C0hat (a+1) + C0hat (a+2)) ✓ then linarith.
Hmm wait — actually looking at the error display: `a✝ : C0hat a + C0hat (a + 1) + C0hat (a + 2) < ∑ ...` — the linarith at the calc's middle step — with h1's bound being C0hat (a − 1 + 1) and h3's C0hat (a + 1 + 1) — as suspected, atom mismatch. Fix with the rewrites.
3. Also fix the named-arg for both sum_union_inter uses: s₁/s₂.
Fixing: `sum_union_inter`'s args are `s₁/s₂`, `C0hat_mono` is in LiGapCircles (circular import — prove inline), and the `a−1+1` form needs rewriting.
tool: Edit
input
{
"file_path": "D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiContour.lean",
"old_string": " have hu1 := Finset.sum_union_inter (s := (zeroWindow_finite (a - 1)).toFinset)\n (t := (zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset \u222a (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset)\n (f := fun \u03c1 => (zeroMult \u03c1 : \u211d))\n have hnn : (0 : \u211d) \u2264 \u2211 \u03c1 \u2208 (zeroWindow_finite (a - 1)).toFinset \u2229\n ((zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset \u222a (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset),\n (zeroMult \u03c1 : \u211d) :=\n Finset.sum_nonneg (fun \u03c1 _ => Nat.cast_nonneg _)\n have hu2 := Finset.sum_union_inter (s := (zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset)\n (t := (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset) (f := fun \u03c1 => (zeroMult \u03c1 : \u211d))\n have hnn2 : (0 : \u211d) \u2264 \u2211 \u03c1 \u2208 (zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset \u2229\n (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset, (zeroMult \u03c1 : \u211d) :=\n Finset.sum_nonneg (fun \u03c1 _ => Nat.cast_nonneg _)\n linarith\n have h1 := hZC (a - 1) (by linarith)\n have h2 := hZC a (by linarith)\n have h3 := hZC (a + 1) (by linarith)\n have hmono1 : C0hat a \u2264 C0hat (a + 2) := C0hat_mono (by linarith) (by linarith)\n have hmono2 : C0hat (a + 1) \u2264 C0hat (a + 2) := C0hat_mono (by linarith) (by linarith)",
"new_string": " have hu1 := Finset.sum_union_inter (s\u2081 := (zeroWindow_finite (a - 1)).toFinset)\n (s\u2082 := (zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset \u222a (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset)\n (f := fun \u03c1 => (zeroMult \u03c1 : \u211d))\n have hnn : (0 : \u211d) \u2264 \u2211 \u03c1 \u2208 (zeroWindow_finite (a - 1)).toFinset \u2229\n ((zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset \u222a (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset),\n (zeroMult \u03c1 : \u211d) :=\n Finset.sum_nonneg (fun \u03c1 _ => Nat.cast_nonneg _)\n have hu2 := Finset.sum_union_inter (s\u2081 := (zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset)\n (s\u2082 := (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset) (f := fun \u03c1 => (zeroMult \u03c1 : \u211d))\n have hnn2 : (0 : \u211d) \u2264 \u2211 \u03c1 \u2208 (zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset \u2229\n (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset, (zeroMult \u03c1 : \u211d) :=\n Finset.sum_nonneg (fun \u03c1 _ => Nat.cast_nonneg _)\n linarith\n have h1 : (\u2211 \u03c1 \u2208 (zeroWindow_finite (a - 1)).toFinset, (zeroMult \u03c1 : \u211d)) \u2264\n C0hat a := by\n have h := hZC (a - 1) (by linarith)\n rwa [show a - 1 + 1 = a from by ring] at h\n have h2 := hZC a (by linarith)\n have h3 : (\u2211 \u03c1 \u2208 (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset, (zeroMult \u03c1 : \u211d)) \u2264\n C0hat (a + 2) := by\n have h := hZC (a + 1) (by linarith)\n rwa [show a + 1 + 1 = a + 2 from by ring] at h\n have hlog1 : Real.log (a + 2) \u2264 Real.log (a + 2 + 2) :=\n Real.log_le_log (by positivity) (by linarith)\n have hlog2 : Real.log (Real.log (a + 2)) \u2264 Real.log (Real.log (a + 2 + 2)) :=\n Real.log_le_log (Real.log_pos (by linarith)) hlog1\n have hmono1 : C0hat a \u2264 C0hat (a + 2) := by\n unfold C0hat\n linarith [hlog1, hlog2]\n have hmono2 : C0hat (a + 1) \u2264 C0hat (a + 2) := by\n unfold C0hat\n have h1' : Real.log (a + 1 + 2) \u2264 Real.log (a + 2 + 2) :=\n Real.log_le_log (by positivity) (by linarith)\n have h2' : Real.log (Real.log (a + 1 + 2)) \u2264 Real.log (Real.log (a + 2 + 2)) :=\n Real.log_le_log (Real.log_pos (by linarith)) h1'\n linarith [h1', h2']"
}
raw content_json (database row)
[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"Three errors:\n\n1. **Finset.sum_union_inter named args**: the params are `s₁`/`s₂` (not s/t). Fix: `(s₁ := ...) (s₂ := ...)`. Also f — probably `{f}` implicit — keep `(f := ...)`.\n\n2. **C0hat_mono unknown**: it's in LiGapCircles.lean — LiContour doesn't import LiGapCircles. Options: import it (LiGapCircles imports LiContour — CIRCULAR!). C0hat_mono is in LiGapCircles which imports LiContour (for ZeroCountProp/exists_zero_avoiding_T?) — so LiContour can't import LiGapCircles. Alternative: prove the monotonicity inline (C0hat is monotone in t: derivative-free — log(t+2) and log log(t+2) are monotone — prove directly: Real.log_le_log + Real.log_le_log composition):\n```lean\n have hmono1 : C0hat a ≤ C0hat (a + 2) := by\n unfold C0hat\n have h1 : Real.log (a + 2) ≤ Real.log (a + 2 + 2) :=\n Real.log_le_log (by positivity) (by linarith)\n have h2 : Real.log (Real.log (a + 2)) ≤ Real.log (Real.log (a + 2 + 2)) := by\n apply Real.log_le_log (Real.log_pos (by linarith)) h1\n linarith\n```\nWait — Real.log_le_log signature: Real.log_le_log (hx : 0 < x) (h : x ≤ y) : log x ≤ log y ✓. For h2: Real.log_le_log (show 0 < Real.log (a+2) from Real.log_pos (by linarith : 1 < a+2... a ≥ 3 so a+2 ≥ 5 > e ✓ 1 < a+2 via linarith)) h1 ✓.\nNote the C0hat argument shift: C0hat(a+2) unfolds to 0.433·log(a+2+2) + ... — the def C0hat t := 0.433·log(t+2)+...: C0hat (a+2) → log((a+2)+2) = log(a+2+2) ✓.\nAlso the third error shows h1's bound: C0hat (a − 1 + 1) — the hZC (a−1) gives ≤ C0hat ((a−1)+1) = C0hat a — syntactically `C0hat (a - 1 + 1)` ≠ `C0hat a`! linarith can't see them as equal (they're defeq but linarith works syntactically on atoms). Fix: convert h1's bound: have h1 := hZC (a-1) ... gives ≤ C0hat (a−1+1); rewrite: `rw [show a - 1 + 1 = a from by ring] at h1`? or pass the bound differently: hZC's statement: ≤ C0hat (t + 1) with t := a−1: C0hat ((a−1)+1) — provide a rewritten version:\n```lean\n have h1 : (∑ ρ ∈ (zeroWindow_finite (a - 1)).toFinset, (zeroMult ρ : ℝ)) ≤ C0hat a := by\n have h := hZC (a - 1) (by linarith)\n rwa [show a - 1 + 1 = a from by ring] at h\n```\nAnd h3 : ≤ C0hat (a+1+1): rewrite to C0hat (a+2): rwa [show a + 1 + 1 = a + 2 from by ring] at h3. Then the final linarith: hsum1 + hsum2 gives Σ_wide ≤ C0hat a + C0hat (a+1) + C0hat (a+2)... wait hsum2's RHS is Σ(a−1) + (Σa + Σ(a+1)) ≤ C0hat a + (C0hat (a+1) + C0hat (a+2)) ✓ then linarith.\n\nHmm wait — actually looking at the error display: `a✝ : C0hat a + C0hat (a + 1) + C0hat (a + 2) < ∑ ...` — the linarith at the calc's middle step — with h1's bound being C0hat (a − 1 + 1) and h3's C0hat (a + 1 + 1) — as suspected, atom mismatch. Fix with the rewrites.\n\n3. Also fix the named-arg for both sum_union_inter uses: s₁/s₂.","signature":""},{"type":"text","text":"Fixing: `sum_union_inter`'s args are `s₁/s₂`, `C0hat_mono` is in LiGapCircles (circular import — prove inline), and the `a−1+1` form needs rewriting."},{"type":"tool_use","id":"Edit_260","name":"Edit","input":{"file_path":"D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiContour.lean","old_string":" have hu1 := Finset.sum_union_inter (s := (zeroWindow_finite (a - 1)).toFinset)\n (t := (zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset ∪ (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset)\n (f := fun ρ => (zeroMult ρ : ℝ))\n have hnn : (0 : ℝ) ≤ ∑ ρ ∈ (zeroWindow_finite (a - 1)).toFinset ∩\n ((zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset ∪ (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset),\n (zeroMult ρ : ℝ) :=\n Finset.sum_nonneg (fun ρ _ => Nat.cast_nonneg _)\n have hu2 := Finset.sum_union_inter (s := (zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset)\n (t := (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset) (f := fun ρ => (zeroMult ρ : ℝ))\n have hnn2 : (0 : ℝ) ≤ ∑ ρ ∈ (zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset ∩\n (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset, (zeroMult ρ : ℝ) :=\n Finset.sum_nonneg (fun ρ _ => Nat.cast_nonneg _)\n linarith\n have h1 := hZC (a - 1) (by linarith)\n have h2 := hZC a (by linarith)\n have h3 := hZC (a + 1) (by linarith)\n have hmono1 : C0hat a ≤ C0hat (a + 2) := C0hat_mono (by linarith) (by linarith)\n have hmono2 : C0hat (a + 1) ≤ C0hat (a + 2) := C0hat_mono (by linarith) (by linarith)","new_string":" have hu1 := Finset.sum_union_inter (s₁ := (zeroWindow_finite (a - 1)).toFinset)\n (s₂ := (zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset ∪ (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset)\n (f := fun ρ => (zeroMult ρ : ℝ))\n have hnn : (0 : ℝ) ≤ ∑ ρ ∈ (zeroWindow_finite (a - 1)).toFinset ∩\n ((zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset ∪ (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset),\n (zeroMult ρ : ℝ) :=\n Finset.sum_nonneg (fun ρ _ => Nat.cast_nonneg _)\n have hu2 := Finset.sum_union_inter (s₁ := (zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset)\n (s₂ := (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset) (f := fun ρ => (zeroMult ρ : ℝ))\n have hnn2 : (0 : ℝ) ≤ ∑ ρ ∈ (zeroWindow_finite a).toFinset ∩\n (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset, (zeroMult ρ : ℝ) :=\n Finset.sum_nonneg (fun ρ _ => Nat.cast_nonneg _)\n linarith\n have h1 : (∑ ρ ∈ (zeroWindow_finite (a - 1)).toFinset, (zeroMult ρ : ℝ)) ≤\n C0hat a := by\n have h := hZC (a - 1) (by linarith)\n rwa [show a - 1 + 1 = a from by ring] at h\n have h2 := hZC a (by linarith)\n have h3 : (∑ ρ ∈ (zeroWindow_finite (a + 1)).toFinset, (zeroMult ρ : ℝ)) ≤\n C0hat (a + 2) := by\n have h := hZC (a + 1) (by linarith)\n rwa [show a + 1 + 1 = a + 2 from by ring] at h\n have hlog1 : Real.log (a + 2) ≤ Real.log (a + 2 + 2) :=\n Real.log_le_log (by positivity) (by linarith)\n have hlog2 : Real.log (Real.log (a + 2)) ≤ Real.log (Real.log (a + 2 + 2)) :=\n Real.log_le_log (Real.log_pos (by linarith)) hlog1\n have hmono1 : C0hat a ≤ C0hat (a + 2) := by\n unfold C0hat\n linarith [hlog1, hlog2]\n have hmono2 : C0hat (a + 1) ≤ C0hat (a + 2) := by\n unfold C0hat\n have h1' : Real.log (a + 1 + 2) ≤ Real.log (a + 2 + 2) :=\n Real.log_le_log (by positivity) (by linarith)\n have h2' : Real.log (Real.log (a + 1 + 2)) ≤ Real.log (Real.log (a + 2 + 2)) :=\n Real.log_le_log (Real.log_pos (by linarith)) h1'\n linarith [h1', h2']"},"extra_content":null}]