← Session 35 — ii′-6-R: Lagarias 6.1 right-tail re-proof (E-032/D-073)
thinking (2483 chars)
Progress: only one goal remains. The kFun_conj warning cleared, h1 fixed, (n := n) fixed. Now the final step: goal is
```
star(kFun n s) * -(star(deriv ζ s)/star(ζ s)) = star (kFun n s * -(deriv ζ s / ζ s))
```
push_cast didn't fire (no goals changed? "unsolved goals" with the RHS still starred). push_cast didn't touch the RHS star. Hmm — push_cast works on `starRingEnd`? The `star` coercion push lemmas — maybe push_cast only handles `↑` coercions and `star` on types like ℂ×ℝ. For starRingEnd ℂ (a RingHom application), the normalization lemmas are map_mul/map_neg/map_div — which simp only would apply. Let me just use `rw [map_mul, map_neg, map_div]` — the earlier map_div error was "pattern ?f (?a / ?b) not found". The current goal's RHS: `star (kFun n s * -(deriv ζ s / ζ s))`. rw [map_mul] rewrites to `star(kFun n s) * star(-(deriv ζ s / ζ s))` ✓; rw [map_neg] → `star(kFun n s) * (-star(deriv ζ s / ζ s))` ✓; rw [map_div] → `star(kFun n s) * (-(star(deriv ζ s)/star(ζ s)))` ✓ = LHS ✓.
Why did map_div fail before? Before push_cast, the sequence was `rw [kFun_conj, _root_.riemannZeta_conj, h1, map_mul, map_neg, map_div]` — at map_div the goal's RHS was `star(kFun n s) * -(starRingEnd ℂ (deriv riemannZeta s / riemannZeta s))` — hmm — after map_neg, the term is `-(starRingEnd ℂ (deriv riemannZeta s / riemannZeta s))` — map_div should match the inner `starRingEnd ℂ (deriv ζ s / ζ s)`... The error message showed the goal with RHS `-(starRingEnd ℂ) (deriv riemannZeta s / riemannZeta s)` and said pattern `?f (?a / ?b)` not found. That IS the pattern...
OH WAIT. I bet map_div in this Mathlib is stated for `DivisionRing` with a **MonoidWithZeroHom** or is the `map_div` for RatFunc/NNReal... — OR the issue: `map_div` might be tagged with side conditions making rw's first unifier pick a DIFFERENT instance (e.g., it unified ?f with `id` or a coercion first and failed). The rw error was at col 64 — the whole rewrite chain failed at map_div with the unifier unable to match. Hmm.
Alternative that always works: `simp only [map_mul, map_neg, map_div]` — simp's matching is more robust (it uses congruence and instance synthesis properly). Or `push_cast [← map_div]`... Let me just try `simp only [map_mul, map_neg, map_div]`. If that fails, `map_div₀`? Let me check what map_div exists in this Mathlib for RingHom:
Actually — the cleanest: `map_div` IS a simp lemma and simp only will use it. Let me replace push_cast with simp only [map_mul, map_neg, map_div].
One goal left — the star-division normalization. `simp only` has more robust matching than the `rw` chain for the `map_div` instance issue.
tool: Edit
input
{
"file_path": "D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiDogLeg.lean",
"old_string": " unfold Jlag\n rw [kFun_conj, _root_.riemannZeta_conj, h1]\n push_cast",
"new_string": " unfold Jlag\n rw [kFun_conj, _root_.riemannZeta_conj, h1]\n simp only [map_mul, map_neg, map_div]"
}
raw content_json (database row)
[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"Progress: only one goal remains. The kFun_conj warning cleared, h1 fixed, (n := n) fixed. Now the final step: goal is\n\n```\nstar(kFun n s) * -(star(deriv ζ s)/star(ζ s)) = star (kFun n s * -(deriv ζ s / ζ s))\n```\n\npush_cast didn't fire (no goals changed? \"unsolved goals\" with the RHS still starred). push_cast didn't touch the RHS star. Hmm — push_cast works on `starRingEnd`? The `star` coercion push lemmas — maybe push_cast only handles `↑` coercions and `star` on types like ℂ×ℝ. For starRingEnd ℂ (a RingHom application), the normalization lemmas are map_mul/map_neg/map_div — which simp only would apply. Let me just use `rw [map_mul, map_neg, map_div]` — the earlier map_div error was \"pattern ?f (?a / ?b) not found\". The current goal's RHS: `star (kFun n s * -(deriv ζ s / ζ s))`. rw [map_mul] rewrites to `star(kFun n s) * star(-(deriv ζ s / ζ s))` ✓; rw [map_neg] → `star(kFun n s) * (-star(deriv ζ s / ζ s))` ✓; rw [map_div] → `star(kFun n s) * (-(star(deriv ζ s)/star(ζ s)))` ✓ = LHS ✓.\n\nWhy did map_div fail before? Before push_cast, the sequence was `rw [kFun_conj, _root_.riemannZeta_conj, h1, map_mul, map_neg, map_div]` — at map_div the goal's RHS was `star(kFun n s) * -(starRingEnd ℂ (deriv riemannZeta s / riemannZeta s))` — hmm — after map_neg, the term is `-(starRingEnd ℂ (deriv riemannZeta s / riemannZeta s))` — map_div should match the inner `starRingEnd ℂ (deriv ζ s / ζ s)`... The error message showed the goal with RHS `-(starRingEnd ℂ) (deriv riemannZeta s / riemannZeta s)` and said pattern `?f (?a / ?b)` not found. That IS the pattern...\n\nOH WAIT. I bet map_div in this Mathlib is stated for `DivisionRing` with a **MonoidWithZeroHom** or is the `map_div` for RatFunc/NNReal... — OR the issue: `map_div` might be tagged with side conditions making rw's first unifier pick a DIFFERENT instance (e.g., it unified ?f with `id` or a coercion first and failed). The rw error was at col 64 — the whole rewrite chain failed at map_div with the unifier unable to match. Hmm.\n\nAlternative that always works: `simp only [map_mul, map_neg, map_div]` — simp's matching is more robust (it uses congruence and instance synthesis properly). Or `push_cast [← map_div]`... Let me just try `simp only [map_mul, map_neg, map_div]`. If that fails, `map_div₀`? Let me check what map_div exists in this Mathlib for RingHom:\n\nActually — the cleanest: `map_div` IS a simp lemma and simp only will use it. Let me replace push_cast with simp only [map_mul, map_neg, map_div].","signature":""},{"type":"text","text":"One goal left — the star-division normalization. `simp only` has more robust matching than the `rw` chain for the `map_div` instance issue."},{"type":"tool_use","id":"Edit_181","name":"Edit","input":{"file_path":"D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiDogLeg.lean","old_string":" unfold Jlag\n rw [kFun_conj, _root_.riemannZeta_conj, h1]\n push_cast","new_string":" unfold Jlag\n rw [kFun_conj, _root_.riemannZeta_conj, h1]\n simp only [map_mul, map_neg, map_div]"},"extra_content":null}]