← Session 35 — ii′-6-R: Lagarias 6.1 right-tail re-proof (E-032/D-073)
thinking (3132 chars)
Checkpoint committed (7e15373). Now the cherry-pick: bracket < 4/3 + IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three from the paused branch `wip/c-1.5-margin-redo` (642d47a) onto master. These are the ONLY two items I need from that branch (NOT the k-shift infrastructure).
The wip branch's LiSkeleton.lean has:
1. `iimaj_bracket_bound {s} (hs : √20 ≤ s) : ... < 4 / 3` (the strengthened bracket, same proof as master's < 2 but with the final `norm_num` giving < 4/3)
2. `IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three {n} (hn : 20 ≤ n) : deriv (deriv IIMaj) n < 1 / (3 * n)` (the strengthened IIMaj″ bound)
Master's LiSkeleton.lean has:
1. `iimaj_bracket_bound ... < 2`
2. `IIMaj_deriv2_lt ... < 1 / (2 * n)`
Cherry-pick approach: apply the same two changes to master's LiSkeleton.lean:
1. iimaj_bracket_bound: `< 2` → `< 4 / 3` (the certified product 4.56·1.2237·0.2124·1.1099 = 1.3155 < 1.3333 ✓ — same proof, last line norm_num).
2. IIMaj_deriv2_lt → IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three with < 1/(3n) (the e : 1/(3n) = (4/3)/(4n) variant).
Then update the convexity consumer: master's marginTilde_convex uses `IIMaj_deriv2_lt` once (line ~2388: `have hIIM := IIMaj_deriv2_lt (show 20 ≤ n by linarith)`). With the mIIM coefficient changing from (−1) to (−1.5) in the dog-leg Bn (the mIIM block), the convexity needs 1.5·IIMaj″ < 1/(2n) ⟸ IIMaj″ < 1/(3n) ✓ IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three.
Wait — actually, let me reconsider the mIIM coefficient. The dog-leg Bn:
- I_I piece: IIMaj(n) [coefficient 1]
- dog-leg: 2·DogLegRight with DogLegRight = VLeft + 8.38 + IIMaj/4: the IIMaj/4 × 2 = IIMaj/2 [coefficient 1/2]
- Total IIMaj: 1 + 1/2 = 1.5 ✓
So the mIIM block in marginExpanded: (−1)·IIMaj → (−1.5)·IIMaj. The convexity: 1.5·IIMaj″ < 1/(2n) ⟸ bracket < 4/3 ⟸ the cherry-picked strengthening ✓.
Hmm wait — do I even need the cherry-pick on master, or can the convexity re-proof use the EXISTING master lemmas with a different slack accounting? Master's IIMaj_deriv2_lt gives IIMaj″ < 1/(2n). The dog-leg mIIM is 1.5: 1.5·IIMaj″ < 1.5·(1/(2n)) = 1.5/(2n) = 3/(4n) vs the margiñ″'s leading 1/(2n) = 2/(4n) — 3/(4n) > 2/(4n) ✗ fails. So YES, the cherry-pick strengthening is needed (1.5·(4/3)/(4n) = 2/(4n) = 1/(2n) ✓ strict).
Cherry-pick plan:
1. From the wip branch (642d47a), extract the two exact code blocks (iimaj_bracket_bound's doc+final-norm_num change and IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three) — actually simplest: apply the same two edits to master's LiSkeleton.lean directly (I know exactly what they are from the earlier c = 1.5 work):
- iimaj_bracket_bound: doc comment + last line `_ < 4 / 3 := by norm_num`.
- IIMaj_deriv2_lt → IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three (statement < 1/(3n), proof with e : 1/(3n) = (4/3)/(4n)).
2. The mIIM coefficient (−1) → (−1.5) happens in the ii′-6-a2 Bn redefinition (marginExpanded's mIIM block + vIIM in marginTilde_convex).
Let me do the cherry-pick first (small edits on master's LiSkeleton.lean), build-check, then ii′-6-a2's Bn redefinition.
For master's LiSkeleton.lean — the iimaj_bracket_bound is at ~1497-1678 (the same region I edited on the wip branch). Master's version has `_ < 2 := by norm_num` at the end. And IIMaj_deriv2_lt at ~2142-2157. Let me apply.
Checkpoint committed (`7e15373`). Now the cherry-pick: applying the bracket strengthening (< 2 → < 4/3) + IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three to master's LiSkeleton.lean.
tool: TodoWrite ok
input
{
"todos": [
{
"content": "Checkpoint: journal-040 (DL-0\u2013DL-6) + db session registration + commit",
"status": "completed",
"activeForm": "Writing journal-040 checkpoint"
},
{
"content": "Cherry-pick bracket < 4/3 + IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three onto master (from wip branch, k-shift excluded)",
"status": "in_progress",
"activeForm": "Cherry-picking the bracket strengthening"
},
{
"content": "ii\u2032-6-a2-i: Bn/marginTilde/marginExpanded/mK dog-leg redefinition + eq_expanded/eq_sub + contDiffOn/continuousOn",
"status": "pending",
"activeForm": "Redefining Bn at the dog-leg constants"
},
{
"content": "ii\u2032-6-a2-ii: marginTilde_convex re-proof (id-block lower bound + 1.5\u00b7IIMaj bracket) + base-point re-certification + endpoint margins",
"status": "pending",
"activeForm": "Re-proving margin convexity + base points"
},
{
"content": "Full build + axiom audit + commit ii\u2032-6-a2; then ii\u2032-6-c per the return map",
"status": "pending",
"activeForm": "Closing ii\u2032-6-a2"
}
]
}
result 2026-08-26 10:53:13Z → 2026-08-26 10:53:13Z
{
"oldTodos": [
"content='Checkpoint: journal-040 (DL-0\u2013DL-6) + db session registration + commit' status='in_progress' active_form='Writing journal-040 checkpoint'",
"content='Cherry-pick bracket < 4/3 + IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three onto master (from wip branch, k-shift excluded)' status='pending' active_form='Cherry-picking the bracket strengthening'",
"content='ii\u2032-6-a2-i: Bn/marginTilde/marginExpanded/mK dog-leg redefinition + eq_expanded/eq_sub + contDiffOn/continuousOn' status='pending' active_form='Redefining Bn at the dog-leg constants'",
"content='ii\u2032-6-a2-ii: marginTilde_convex re-proof (id-block lower bound + 1.5\u00b7IIMaj bracket) + base-point re-certification + endpoint margins' status='pending' active_form='Re-proving margin convexity + base points'",
"content='Full build + axiom audit + commit ii\u2032-6-a2; then ii\u2032-6-c per the return map' status='pending' active_form='Closing ii\u2032-6-a2'"
],
"newTodos": [
"content='Checkpoint: journal-040 (DL-0\u2013DL-6) + db session registration + commit' status='completed' active_form='Writing journal-040 checkpoint'",
"content='Cherry-pick bracket < 4/3 + IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three onto master (from wip branch, k-shift excluded)' status='in_progress' active_form='Cherry-picking the bracket strengthening'",
"content='ii\u2032-6-a2-i: Bn/marginTilde/marginExpanded/mK dog-leg redefinition + eq_expanded/eq_sub + contDiffOn/continuousOn' status='pending' active_form='Redefining Bn at the dog-leg constants'",
"content='ii\u2032-6-a2-ii: marginTilde_convex re-proof (id-block lower bound + 1.5\u00b7IIMaj bracket) + base-point re-certification + endpoint margins' status='pending' active_form='Re-proving margin convexity + base points'",
"content='Full build + axiom audit + commit ii\u2032-6-a2; then ii\u2032-6-c per the return map' status='pending' active_form='Closing ii\u2032-6-a2'"
],
"cleared": false
}
tool: Read ok
input
{
"file_path": "D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiSkeleton.lean",
"offset": 1670,
"limit": 12
}
result 2026-08-26 10:53:13Z → 2026-08-26 10:53:13Z
{
"type": "text",
"file": {
"filePath": "D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiSkeleton.lean",
"content": " 4.56 * ((s + 1) / s) * ((b ^ 2 * s + b) * eA) * (1 + Real.exp (-s / 2)) := by ring\n have e' : (4.56 : \u211d) * (1.2237 * 0.2124 * 1.1099) = 4.56 * 1.2237 * 0.2124 * 1.1099 := by ring\n rwa [e, e'] at h3\n calc 4.56 * (2 * (-a * eA - b * eB) + (s + 1) * (a ^ 2 * eA + b ^ 2 * eB)) -\n (4.56 * ((eA + eB) + (s + 1) * (-a * eA - b * eB))) / s\n \u2264 4.56 * (s + 1) * (b ^ 2 + b / s) * (eA + eB) := le_trans hstep1 hstep2\n _ = 4.56 * ((s + 1) / s) * ((b ^ 2 * s + b) * eA) * (1 + Real.exp (-s / 2)) := hstep3\n _ \u2264 4.56 * 1.2237 * 0.2124 * 1.1099 := hchain\n _ < 2 := by norm_num\n\n/-! ### Assembly: regularity bundles -/\n",
"numLines": 12,
"startLine": 1670,
"totalLines": 2793
}
}
raw content_json (database row)
[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"Checkpoint committed (7e15373). Now the cherry-pick: bracket < 4/3 + IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three from the paused branch `wip/c-1.5-margin-redo` (642d47a) onto master. These are the ONLY two items I need from that branch (NOT the k-shift infrastructure).\n\nThe wip branch's LiSkeleton.lean has:\n1. `iimaj_bracket_bound {s} (hs : √20 ≤ s) : ... < 4 / 3` (the strengthened bracket, same proof as master's < 2 but with the final `norm_num` giving < 4/3)\n2. `IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three {n} (hn : 20 ≤ n) : deriv (deriv IIMaj) n < 1 / (3 * n)` (the strengthened IIMaj″ bound)\n\nMaster's LiSkeleton.lean has:\n1. `iimaj_bracket_bound ... < 2`\n2. `IIMaj_deriv2_lt ... < 1 / (2 * n)`\n\nCherry-pick approach: apply the same two changes to master's LiSkeleton.lean:\n1. iimaj_bracket_bound: `< 2` → `< 4 / 3` (the certified product 4.56·1.2237·0.2124·1.1099 = 1.3155 < 1.3333 ✓ — same proof, last line norm_num).\n2. IIMaj_deriv2_lt → IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three with < 1/(3n) (the e : 1/(3n) = (4/3)/(4n) variant).\n\nThen update the convexity consumer: master's marginTilde_convex uses `IIMaj_deriv2_lt` once (line ~2388: `have hIIM := IIMaj_deriv2_lt (show 20 ≤ n by linarith)`). With the mIIM coefficient changing from (−1) to (−1.5) in the dog-leg Bn (the mIIM block), the convexity needs 1.5·IIMaj″ < 1/(2n) ⟸ IIMaj″ < 1/(3n) ✓ IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three.\n\nWait — actually, let me reconsider the mIIM coefficient. The dog-leg Bn:\n- I_I piece: IIMaj(n) [coefficient 1]\n- dog-leg: 2·DogLegRight with DogLegRight = VLeft + 8.38 + IIMaj/4: the IIMaj/4 × 2 = IIMaj/2 [coefficient 1/2]\n- Total IIMaj: 1 + 1/2 = 1.5 ✓\n\nSo the mIIM block in marginExpanded: (−1)·IIMaj → (−1.5)·IIMaj. The convexity: 1.5·IIMaj″ < 1/(2n) ⟸ bracket < 4/3 ⟸ the cherry-picked strengthening ✓.\n\nHmm wait — do I even need the cherry-pick on master, or can the convexity re-proof use the EXISTING master lemmas with a different slack accounting? Master's IIMaj_deriv2_lt gives IIMaj″ < 1/(2n). The dog-leg mIIM is 1.5: 1.5·IIMaj″ < 1.5·(1/(2n)) = 1.5/(2n) = 3/(4n) vs the margiñ″'s leading 1/(2n) = 2/(4n) — 3/(4n) > 2/(4n) ✗ fails. So YES, the cherry-pick strengthening is needed (1.5·(4/3)/(4n) = 2/(4n) = 1/(2n) ✓ strict).\n\nCherry-pick plan:\n1. From the wip branch (642d47a), extract the two exact code blocks (iimaj_bracket_bound's doc+final-norm_num change and IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three) — actually simplest: apply the same two edits to master's LiSkeleton.lean directly (I know exactly what they are from the earlier c = 1.5 work):\n - iimaj_bracket_bound: doc comment + last line `_ < 4 / 3 := by norm_num`.\n - IIMaj_deriv2_lt → IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three (statement < 1/(3n), proof with e : 1/(3n) = (4/3)/(4n)).\n2. The mIIM coefficient (−1) → (−1.5) happens in the ii′-6-a2 Bn redefinition (marginExpanded's mIIM block + vIIM in marginTilde_convex).\n\nLet me do the cherry-pick first (small edits on master's LiSkeleton.lean), build-check, then ii′-6-a2's Bn redefinition.\n\nFor master's LiSkeleton.lean — the iimaj_bracket_bound is at ~1497-1678 (the same region I edited on the wip branch). Master's version has `_ < 2 := by norm_num` at the end. And IIMaj_deriv2_lt at ~2142-2157. Let me apply.","signature":""},{"type":"text","text":"Checkpoint committed (`7e15373`). Now the cherry-pick: applying the bracket strengthening (< 2 → < 4/3) + IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three to master's LiSkeleton.lean."},{"type":"tool_use","id":"TodoWrite_533","name":"TodoWrite","input":{"todos":[{"content":"Checkpoint: journal-040 (DL-0–DL-6) + db session registration + commit","status":"completed","activeForm":"Writing journal-040 checkpoint"},{"content":"Cherry-pick bracket < 4/3 + IIMaj_deriv2_lt_three onto master (from wip branch, k-shift excluded)","status":"in_progress","activeForm":"Cherry-picking the bracket strengthening"},{"content":"ii′-6-a2-i: Bn/marginTilde/marginExpanded/mK dog-leg redefinition + eq_expanded/eq_sub + contDiffOn/continuousOn","status":"pending","activeForm":"Redefining Bn at the dog-leg constants"},{"content":"ii′-6-a2-ii: marginTilde_convex re-proof (id-block lower bound + 1.5·IIMaj bracket) + base-point re-certification + endpoint margins","status":"pending","activeForm":"Re-proving margin convexity + base points"},{"content":"Full build + axiom audit + commit ii′-6-a2; then ii′-6-c per the return map","status":"pending","activeForm":"Closing ii′-6-a2"}]},"extra_content":null},{"type":"tool_use","id":"Read_534","name":"Read","input":{"file_path":"D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiSkeleton.lean","offset":1670,"limit":12},"extra_content":null}]