← Session 36 — ii′-6-DL dog-leg + side bounds; Paper A review
thinking (2684 chars)
`HasDerivAt.pow (h) (n) : HasDerivAt (f ^ n) (n * f x ^ (n - 1) * f') x` — the function is `(f ^ n)` — PI.POWER — `f ^ 2` where f := fun x => x − β — the function is `(fun x => x−β)^2` (Pi.pow!) — NOT `fun y => (y−β)^2`! And h2b := h2a.add_const (δ^2) : HasDerivAt ((fun x => x−β)^2 + fun _ => δ^2)?? — HasDerivAt.add_const (hf) (c) : HasDerivAt (fun y => f y + c) f' — applied to `f ^ n` — gives `fun y => (f^2) y + δ^2` — hmm — `fun y => ((fun x => x−β)^2) y + δ^2` — with Pi.pow applied — beta-reducible to (y−β)^2 ✓ defeq.
The derivative: `n * f x ^ (n - 1) * f'` with n := 2, f x := σ−β, f' := 1: `(2:ℕ... ` — wait `n * f x ^ (n - 1) * f'` — n : ℕ — the multiplication `n * ...` — n coerced to ℝ? — `↑2 * (σ−β)^(2−1) * 1`.
So convert's goal could be:
- function: `fun σ => (σ−β)^2+δ^2` vs `fun y => ((fun x => x−β)^2) y + δ^2` — the Pi.pow beta-redex — convert using 1's defeq-check should reduce it ✓...
- OR convert leaves the function goal AND the derivative goal — with "case h" being one of them...
Ugh — I've been speculating too long. The robust fix for the whole h2: use `by fun_prop`? — fun_prop with the Pi.pow form — it handles `fun σ => (σ−β)^2+δ^2` — computes derivative — the stated derivative 2*(σ−β) — fun_prop's HasDerivAt support: `HasDerivAt (fun x => (x-c)^2) (2*(x-c)) x` — fun_prop should prove via its rules (HasDerivAt.pow is a fun_prop lemma? or it uses deriv computation). Let me check: fun_prop does support HasDerivAt for elementary functions ✓ (it's the standard way: `by fun_prop`). But the EXACT derivative match: fun_prop computes the derivative via its own simp-normal form and then compares with the stated one using `rfl`/simp — 2*(σ−β) vs its computed 2*(σ−β)*1 or similar — usually closes ✓.
Alternative safest: sidestep h2 entirely — prove the sqrt-chain derivative via the OUTER composition: HasDerivAt (fun σ => √((σ−β)^2+δ^2)) — I can ALSO get it from `(hasDerivAt_id σ).sub_const β |>.pow 2 |>.add_const _ |>.sqrt _` with simpa wrappers. Let me write:
```lean
have h4 : HasDerivAt (fun σ => Real.sqrt ((σ - β) ^ 2 + δ ^ 2))
(2 * (σ - β) / (2 * Real.sqrt ((σ - β) ^ 2 + δ ^ 2))) σ := by
have h2 : HasDerivAt (fun σ => (σ - β) ^ 2 + δ ^ 2) (2 * (σ - β)) σ := by
have h2a := ((hasDerivAt_id σ).sub_const β).pow 2
have h2b := h2a.add_const (δ ^ 2)
simpa using h2b
exact h2.sqrt hhσ.ne'
```
`simpa using h2b` — simp normalizes: Pi.pow → applied pow (via Pi.pow_apply?), pow_one, mul_one, Nat.cast_ofNat (or Nat.cast_two → 2), — simp should turn h2b's statement into exactly the goal ✓ likely.
Let me apply: h2's convert;ring → simpa using h2b. And hΣcont/hRHScont → continuous_finsetSum.
`HasDerivAt.pow` produces a `Pi.pow` form — that's what tripped the convert/ring. Fixing with `simpa` and the `continuous_finsetSum` name.
tool: Edit
input
{
"replace_all": false,
"file_path": "D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiSideBounds.lean",
"old_string": " have h2 : HasDerivAt (fun \u03c3 => (\u03c3 - \u03b2) ^ 2 + \u03b4 ^ 2) (2 * (\u03c3 - \u03b2)) \u03c3 := by\n have h2a := ((hasDerivAt_id \u03c3).sub_const \u03b2).pow 2\n have h2b := h2a.add_const (\u03b4 ^ 2)\n convert h2b using 1\n ring",
"new_string": " have h2 : HasDerivAt (fun \u03c3 => (\u03c3 - \u03b2) ^ 2 + \u03b4 ^ 2) (2 * (\u03c3 - \u03b2)) \u03c3 := by\n have h2a := ((hasDerivAt_id \u03c3).sub_const \u03b2).pow 2\n have h2b := h2a.add_const (\u03b4 ^ 2)\n simpa using h2b"
}
tool: Edit
input
{
"replace_all": false,
"file_path": "D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiSideBounds.lean",
"old_string": " have h\u03a3cont : Continuous fun \u03c3 : \u211d =>\n \u2211 \u03c1 \u2208 nearZerosSub T, (zeroMult \u03c1.1 : \u2102) /\n (((\u03c3 : \u211d) + (T : \u211d) * Complex.I) - \u03c1.1) := by\n apply continuous_finset_sum\n intro \u03c1 h\u03c1\n exact Continuous.div continuous_const (hpath.sub continuous_const) (hden \u03c1 h\u03c1)",
"new_string": " have h\u03a3cont : Continuous fun \u03c3 : \u211d =>\n \u2211 \u03c1 \u2208 nearZerosSub T, (zeroMult \u03c1.1 : \u2102) /\n (((\u03c3 : \u211d) + (T : \u211d) * Complex.I) - \u03c1.1) := by\n exact continuous_finsetSum _ (fun \u03c1 h\u03c1 =>\n Continuous.div continuous_const (hpath.sub continuous_const) (hden \u03c1 h\u03c1))"
}
tool: Edit
input
{
"replace_all": false,
"file_path": "D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiSideBounds.lean",
"old_string": " have hRHScont : Continuous fun \u03c3 : \u211d =>\n \u2211 \u03c1 \u2208 nearZerosSub T, (zeroMult \u03c1.1 : \u211d) *\n (1 / Real.sqrt ((\u03c3 - \u03c1.1.re) ^ 2 + (T - \u03c1.1.im) ^ 2)) := by\n apply continuous_finset_sum\n intro \u03c1 h\u03c1\n exact htermcont \u03c1 h\u03c1",
"new_string": " have hRHScont : Continuous fun \u03c3 : \u211d =>\n \u2211 \u03c1 \u2208 nearZerosSub T, (zeroMult \u03c1.1 : \u211d) *\n (1 / Real.sqrt ((\u03c3 - \u03c1.1.re) ^ 2 + (T - \u03c1.1.im) ^ 2)) := by\n exact continuous_finsetSum _ (fun \u03c1 h\u03c1 => htermcont \u03c1 h\u03c1)"
}
raw content_json (database row)
[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"`HasDerivAt.pow (h) (n) : HasDerivAt (f ^ n) (n * f x ^ (n - 1) * f') x` — the function is `(f ^ n)` — PI.POWER — `f ^ 2` where f := fun x => x − β — the function is `(fun x => x−β)^2` (Pi.pow!) — NOT `fun y => (y−β)^2`! And h2b := h2a.add_const (δ^2) : HasDerivAt ((fun x => x−β)^2 + fun _ => δ^2)?? — HasDerivAt.add_const (hf) (c) : HasDerivAt (fun y => f y + c) f' — applied to `f ^ n` — gives `fun y => (f^2) y + δ^2` — hmm — `fun y => ((fun x => x−β)^2) y + δ^2` — with Pi.pow applied — beta-reducible to (y−β)^2 ✓ defeq.\n\nThe derivative: `n * f x ^ (n - 1) * f'` with n := 2, f x := σ−β, f' := 1: `(2:ℕ... ` — wait `n * f x ^ (n - 1) * f'` — n : ℕ — the multiplication `n * ...` — n coerced to ℝ? — `↑2 * (σ−β)^(2−1) * 1`.\n\nSo convert's goal could be:\n- function: `fun σ => (σ−β)^2+δ^2` vs `fun y => ((fun x => x−β)^2) y + δ^2` — the Pi.pow beta-redex — convert using 1's defeq-check should reduce it ✓...\n- OR convert leaves the function goal AND the derivative goal — with \"case h\" being one of them...\n\nUgh — I've been speculating too long. The robust fix for the whole h2: use `by fun_prop`? — fun_prop with the Pi.pow form — it handles `fun σ => (σ−β)^2+δ^2` — computes derivative — the stated derivative 2*(σ−β) — fun_prop's HasDerivAt support: `HasDerivAt (fun x => (x-c)^2) (2*(x-c)) x` — fun_prop should prove via its rules (HasDerivAt.pow is a fun_prop lemma? or it uses deriv computation). Let me check: fun_prop does support HasDerivAt for elementary functions ✓ (it's the standard way: `by fun_prop`). But the EXACT derivative match: fun_prop computes the derivative via its own simp-normal form and then compares with the stated one using `rfl`/simp — 2*(σ−β) vs its computed 2*(σ−β)*1 or similar — usually closes ✓.\n\nAlternative safest: sidestep h2 entirely — prove the sqrt-chain derivative via the OUTER composition: HasDerivAt (fun σ => √((σ−β)^2+δ^2)) — I can ALSO get it from `(hasDerivAt_id σ).sub_const β |>.pow 2 |>.add_const _ |>.sqrt _` with simpa wrappers. Let me write:\n\n```lean\n have h4 : HasDerivAt (fun σ => Real.sqrt ((σ - β) ^ 2 + δ ^ 2))\n (2 * (σ - β) / (2 * Real.sqrt ((σ - β) ^ 2 + δ ^ 2))) σ := by\n have h2 : HasDerivAt (fun σ => (σ - β) ^ 2 + δ ^ 2) (2 * (σ - β)) σ := by\n have h2a := ((hasDerivAt_id σ).sub_const β).pow 2\n have h2b := h2a.add_const (δ ^ 2)\n simpa using h2b\n exact h2.sqrt hhσ.ne'\n```\n\n`simpa using h2b` — simp normalizes: Pi.pow → applied pow (via Pi.pow_apply?), pow_one, mul_one, Nat.cast_ofNat (or Nat.cast_two → 2), — simp should turn h2b's statement into exactly the goal ✓ likely.\n\nLet me apply: h2's convert;ring → simpa using h2b. And hΣcont/hRHScont → continuous_finsetSum.","signature":""},{"type":"text","text":"`HasDerivAt.pow` produces a `Pi.pow` form — that's what tripped the convert/ring. Fixing with `simpa` and the `continuous_finsetSum` name."},{"type":"tool_use","id":"Edit_117","name":"Edit","input":{"replace_all":false,"file_path":"D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiSideBounds.lean","old_string":" have h2 : HasDerivAt (fun σ => (σ - β) ^ 2 + δ ^ 2) (2 * (σ - β)) σ := by\n have h2a := ((hasDerivAt_id σ).sub_const β).pow 2\n have h2b := h2a.add_const (δ ^ 2)\n convert h2b using 1\n ring","new_string":" have h2 : HasDerivAt (fun σ => (σ - β) ^ 2 + δ ^ 2) (2 * (σ - β)) σ := by\n have h2a := ((hasDerivAt_id σ).sub_const β).pow 2\n have h2b := h2a.add_const (δ ^ 2)\n simpa using h2b"},"extra_content":null},{"type":"tool_use","id":"Edit_118","name":"Edit","input":{"replace_all":false,"file_path":"D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiSideBounds.lean","old_string":" have hΣcont : Continuous fun σ : ℝ =>\n ∑ ρ ∈ nearZerosSub T, (zeroMult ρ.1 : ℂ) /\n (((σ : ℝ) + (T : ℝ) * Complex.I) - ρ.1) := by\n apply continuous_finset_sum\n intro ρ hρ\n exact Continuous.div continuous_const (hpath.sub continuous_const) (hden ρ hρ)","new_string":" have hΣcont : Continuous fun σ : ℝ =>\n ∑ ρ ∈ nearZerosSub T, (zeroMult ρ.1 : ℂ) /\n (((σ : ℝ) + (T : ℝ) * Complex.I) - ρ.1) := by\n exact continuous_finsetSum _ (fun ρ hρ =>\n Continuous.div continuous_const (hpath.sub continuous_const) (hden ρ hρ))"},"extra_content":null},{"type":"tool_use","id":"Edit_119","name":"Edit","input":{"replace_all":false,"file_path":"D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiSideBounds.lean","old_string":" have hRHScont : Continuous fun σ : ℝ =>\n ∑ ρ ∈ nearZerosSub T, (zeroMult ρ.1 : ℝ) *\n (1 / Real.sqrt ((σ - ρ.1.re) ^ 2 + (T - ρ.1.im) ^ 2)) := by\n apply continuous_finset_sum\n intro ρ hρ\n exact htermcont ρ hρ","new_string":" have hRHScont : Continuous fun σ : ℝ =>\n ∑ ρ ∈ nearZerosSub T, (zeroMult ρ.1 : ℝ) *\n (1 / Real.sqrt ((σ - ρ.1.re) ^ 2 + (T - ρ.1.im) ^ 2)) := by\n exact continuous_finsetSum _ (fun ρ hρ => htermcont ρ hρ)"},"extra_content":null}]