Current task: —

← Session 36 — ii′-6-DL dog-leg + side bounds; Paper A review

#2302 assistant 2026-08-26 19:58:31.021 UTC · 481→1854 tok open ⤢
thinking (3782 chars)
`RectangleIntegral' f z w := (1 / (2 * π * I)) • RectangleIntegral f z w` ✓ — so ‖RectInt'‖ = ‖1/(2πi)‖·‖RectInt‖ = (1/(2π))·‖RectInt‖ — with ‖1/(2πi)‖ = 1/‖2πi‖ = 1/(2π·‖i‖) = 1/(2π): ‖(1/(2πi))‖ = 1/‖2 * π * I‖ — ‖2 * π * I‖ = 2·π·‖I‖ = 2π — so ‖1/(2πi)‖ = 1/(2π) — need: ‖2 * π * I‖ = 2π (norm_mul, Complex.norm_I, and π as a complex: ‖(π : ℂ)‖ = π — and the 2 : ℂ norm = 2). And norm_smul : ‖c • x‖ = ‖c‖·‖x‖ — norm_smul for ℂ smul on ℂ — `norm_smul (c : 𝕜) (x : E) : ‖c • x‖ = ‖c‖ * ‖x‖`? — for ℝ or ℂ scalars — `norm_smul` ✓ (used in VIntegral_norm: rw [norm_smul, Complex.norm_I, one_mul] ✓). Now the plan for 6-d. Statement: ```lean theorem sfBoundProp (hRH : RHUpTo (3 * 10 ^ 12)) (hZC : ZeroCountProp) (hZC2 : ZeroCountProp2) (hZCG : ZeroCountGlobalProp) (hNLZ : NoLowZeros) (hMZ : MZeroProp) : SfBoundProp := by intro n hn hN1 -- T from the wide pigeonhole at a := √n have hnR : (100000 : ℝ) ≤ (n : ℝ) := by exact_mod_cast hn have ha : (3 : ℝ) ≤ Real.sqrt (n : ℝ) := by ... (√n ≥ 316) obtain ⟨T, hTn, hTn1, hTwide⟩ := exists_zero_avoiding_T_wide hZC ha -- the sides identity have hsf := sf_abs_le_rectInt_add_zeroSum hZC (by omega : 1 ≤ n) (by ... : 1 ≤ T) hTn hTn1 hTwide -- the bridge have hTle : T ≤ 3 * 10 ^ 12 - 1 := by -- T ≤ √n+1 ≤ √(N₁)+1 = (3·10¹²−1)+1... hmm — n ≤ (3·10¹²−1)² ⟹ √n ≤ 3·10¹²−1 ⟹ T ≤ √n+1 ≤ 3·10¹² ✓ — need T ≤ 3·10¹²−1?? — the bridge needs hTle : T ≤ 3·10¹²−1!! T ≤ √n+1 ≤ (3·10¹²−1)+1 = 3·10¹² — NOT ≤ 3·10¹²−1!!! ``` WAIT — problem: the bridge zeroSum_norm_le_four_FAlt_add_one needs (hTle : T ≤ 3·10¹²−1). But T ∈ [√n, √n+1] with n ≤ N₁ = (3·10¹²−1)² — so √n ≤ 3·10¹²−1 and T ≤ √n+1 ≤ 3·10¹². hTle : T ≤ 3·10¹²−1 is NOT guaranteed when √n is within 1 of the endpoint!! Hmm — but the recipe says "bridge zeroSum_norm_le_four_FAlt_add_one hRH hZCG hNLZ (T ≤ 3×10¹²−1 from n ≤ N₁; 2 ≤ T)". Hmm — T ≤ √n+1 and √n ≤ 3·10¹²−1 gives T ≤ 3·10¹² — the recipe says T ≤ 3×10¹²−1 "from n ≤ N₁" — that's WRONG by 1 unless... — hmm — actually wait: maybe the bridge's hTle is used for the RHUpTo application: ρ.im ≤ T ⟹ re = 1/2 — hRH : RHUpTo (3·10¹²) := ∀ ρ, IsNontrivialZero ρ → |ρ.im| ≤ 3·10¹² → ρ.re = 1/2. The zeros in zeroBothWindow T have |γ| ≤ T+1 ≤ 3·10¹²+1?? — hmm — so actually maybe the bridge's hTle : T ≤ 3·10¹²−1 is used to get |γ| ≤ 3·10¹² for the window zeros: zeroBothWindow T covers |γ| ≤ T+1?? — with T ≤ 3·10¹²−1: |γ| ≤ T+1 ≤ 3·10¹² ✓ — so the bridge NEEDS T ≤ 3·10¹²−1 (so that T+1 ≤ 3·10¹² for RHUpTo). And T ≤ √n+1 with √n ≤ 3·10¹²−1 gives T ≤ 3·10¹² — INSUFFICIENT by the same slack. Hmm — but wait — actually — n ≤ N₁ = (3·10¹²−1)² — if n < N₁ slightly... — the issue is only at the very top of the range. Hmm — but actually — hold on: T ≤ √n + 1 where √n ≤ 3·10¹²−1 — T ≤ 3·10¹². For the bridge I need T ≤ 3·10¹²−1 — i.e., √n + 1 ≤ 3·10¹²−1 ⟺ √n ≤ 3·10¹²−2 ⟺ n ≤ (3·10¹²−2)². But n can be as large as (3·10¹²−1)² > (3·10¹²−2)². CONFLICT at the very top: for n ∈ ((3·10¹²−2)², (3·10¹²−1)²], the bridge's hTle fails?! Hmm wait — let me recheck: SfBoundProp's range: (n:ℝ) ≤ (3·10¹²−1)². T ∈ [√n, √n+1]. Bridge needs T ≤ 3·10¹²−1. Since T ≤ √n+1 ≤ (3·10¹²−1)+1 = 3·10¹², we have T ≤ 3·10¹² but need ≤ 3·10¹²−1. GAP of 1. Hmm — but the ii′-6-b bridge was DESIGNED for this fold (session-038) — surely this was accounted. Let me look at how the bridge's hTle is actually USED — maybe hTle : T ≤ 3·10¹²−1 is just one option and the actual requirement is |γ| ≤ 3·10¹² for window zeros: zeroBothWindow T — let me check zeroBothWindow's def — if it's |γ| ≤ T (not T+1), then |γ| ≤ T ≤ 3·10¹² needs T ≤ 3·10¹² ✓ — but the hypothesis is written as T ≤ 3·10¹²−1... — let me look at the bridge's proof to see what it really needs. Actually — hmm — simplest: check zeroBothWindow_finite/zeroBothWindow def.
Checking the bridge's actual T-range requirement vs what T ≤ √n+1 gives at the top of the range.
tool: Grep ok
input
{
  "pattern": "def zeroBothWindow|zeroBothWindow_finite|hTle",
  "path": "D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiAssembly.lean",
  "output_mode": "content",
  "-A": 6,
  "head_limit": 50
}
result 2026-08-26 19:58:31Z → 2026-08-26 19:58:31Z
mode='content' num_files=0 filenames=[] content='39:def zeroBothWindow (T : ℝ) : Set ℂ :=\n40-  {ρ | IsNontrivialZero ρ ∧ |ρ.im| ≤ T}\n41-\n42-/-- Finiteness of the both-signs window (via Zeta23 `zerosIn_finite`). -/\n43:theorem zeroBothWindow_finite (T : ℝ) : (zeroBothWindow T).Finite := by\n44-  apply Set.Finite.subset (zerosIn_finite (-T - 1) T)\n45-  intro ρ hρ\n46-  refine ⟨hρ.1, ?_, ?_⟩\n47-  · linarith [abs_le.mp hρ.2 |>.1]\n48-  · exact abs_le.mp hρ.2 |>.2\n49-\n--\n81:      ‖∑ ρ ∈ ((zeroBothWindow_finite T).toFinset ∪ {(-2 : ℂ)}),\n82-        (zeroMult ρ: ℂ) * (1 - (ρ / (ρ - 1)) ^ n)‖ := by\n83-  set z:= rectZ T\n84-  set w:= rectW n T\n85-  have hn1sqrt: (1 : ℝ) ≤ Real.sqrt n := Real.one_le_sqrt.mpr (by exact_mod_cast hn)\n86-  have hre: z.re ≤ w.re := by\n87-    rw [rectZ_re, rectW_re]\n--\n198:  set Sz : Finset ℂ := (zeroBothWindow_finite T).toFinset ∪ {(-2 : ℂ)} with hSz_def\n199-  have hSz: ∀ s : ℂ, s ∈ Sz ↔ s ∈ Rectangle z w ∧ zetaA s = 0 := by\n200-    intro s\n201-    constructor\n202-    · intro hs\n203-      rw [hSz_def, Finset.mem_union, Finset.mem_singleton] at hs\n204-      rcases hs with hs | rfl\n205:      · have hmem : s ∈ zeroBothWindow T := (zeroBothWindow_finite T).mem_toFinset.mp hs\n206-        obtain ⟨hnt, himT⟩:= hmem\n207-        have hs1: s ≠ 1 := by\n208-          intro h\n209-          have h22: (1 : ℂ).re < 1 := h ▸ hnt.2.2\n210-          rw [Complex.one_re] at h22\n211-          exact lt_irrefl 1 h22\n--\n259:        apply (zeroBothWindow_finite T).mem_toFinset.mpr\n260-        refine ⟨hnt, ?_⟩\n261-        have hi: s.im ∈ Set.uIcc z.im w.im := hmem.2\n262-        rw [Set.uIcc_of_le him, rectZ_im, rectW_im, Set.mem_Icc] at hi\n263-        exact abs_le.mpr hi\n264-      · have h00: zetaA 0 = 0 := by rwa [h0] at hzA\n265-        rw [zetaA_apply (by norm_num: (0 : ℂ) ≠ 1), riemannZeta_zero] at h00\n--\n336:    (hTle : T ≤ 3 * 10 ^ 12) :\n337:    ‖∑ ρ ∈ (zeroBothWindow_finite T).toFinset,\n338-      (zeroMult ρ: ℂ) * (1 - (ρ / (ρ - 1)) ^ n)‖ ≤\n339:      2 * ∑ ρ ∈ (zeroBothWindow_finite T).toFinset, (zeroMult ρ : ℝ) := by\n340:  calc ‖∑ ρ ∈ (zeroBothWindow_finite T).toFinset,\n341-        (zeroMult ρ: ℂ) * (1 - (ρ / (ρ - 1)) ^ n)‖\n342:      ≤ ∑ ρ ∈ (zeroBothWindow_finite T).toFinset,' num_lines=50 num_matches=None applied_limit=50 applied_offset=None
raw content_json (database row)
[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"`RectangleIntegral' f z w := (1 / (2 * π * I)) • RectangleIntegral f z w` ✓ — so ‖RectInt'‖ = ‖1/(2πi)‖·‖RectInt‖ = (1/(2π))·‖RectInt‖ — with ‖1/(2πi)‖ = 1/‖2πi‖ = 1/(2π·‖i‖) = 1/(2π): ‖(1/(2πi))‖ = 1/‖2 * π * I‖ — ‖2 * π * I‖ = 2·π·‖I‖ = 2π — so ‖1/(2πi)‖ = 1/(2π) — need: ‖2 * π * I‖ = 2π (norm_mul, Complex.norm_I, and π as a complex: ‖(π : ℂ)‖ = π — and the 2 : ℂ norm = 2). And norm_smul : ‖c • x‖ = ‖c‖·‖x‖ — norm_smul for ℂ smul on ℂ — `norm_smul (c : 𝕜) (x : E) : ‖c • x‖ = ‖c‖ * ‖x‖`? — for ℝ or ℂ scalars — `norm_smul` ✓ (used in VIntegral_norm: rw [norm_smul, Complex.norm_I, one_mul] ✓).\n\nNow the plan for 6-d. Statement:\n\n```lean\ntheorem sfBoundProp (hRH : RHUpTo (3 * 10 ^ 12)) (hZC : ZeroCountProp)\n    (hZC2 : ZeroCountProp2) (hZCG : ZeroCountGlobalProp) (hNLZ : NoLowZeros)\n    (hMZ : MZeroProp) : SfBoundProp := by\n  intro n hn hN1\n  -- T from the wide pigeonhole at a := √n\n  have hnR : (100000 : ℝ) ≤ (n : ℝ) := by exact_mod_cast hn\n  have ha : (3 : ℝ) ≤ Real.sqrt (n : ℝ) := by ... (√n ≥ 316)\n  obtain ⟨T, hTn, hTn1, hTwide⟩ := exists_zero_avoiding_T_wide hZC ha\n  -- the sides identity\n  have hsf := sf_abs_le_rectInt_add_zeroSum hZC (by omega : 1 ≤ n) (by ... : 1 ≤ T) hTn hTn1 hTwide\n  -- the bridge\n  have hTle : T ≤ 3 * 10 ^ 12 - 1 := by\n    -- T ≤ √n+1 ≤ √(N₁)+1 = (3·10¹²−1)+1... hmm — n ≤ (3·10¹²−1)² ⟹ √n ≤ 3·10¹²−1 ⟹ T ≤ √n+1 ≤ 3·10¹² ✓ — need T ≤ 3·10¹²−1?? — the bridge needs hTle : T ≤ 3·10¹²−1!! T ≤ √n+1 ≤ (3·10¹²−1)+1 = 3·10¹² — NOT ≤ 3·10¹²−1!!!\n```\n\nWAIT — problem: the bridge zeroSum_norm_le_four_FAlt_add_one needs (hTle : T ≤ 3·10¹²−1). But T ∈ [√n, √n+1] with n ≤ N₁ = (3·10¹²−1)² — so √n ≤ 3·10¹²−1 and T ≤ √n+1 ≤ 3·10¹². hTle : T ≤ 3·10¹²−1 is NOT guaranteed when √n is within 1 of the endpoint!! Hmm — but the recipe says \"bridge zeroSum_norm_le_four_FAlt_add_one hRH hZCG hNLZ (T ≤ 3×10¹²−1 from n ≤ N₁; 2 ≤ T)\". Hmm — T ≤ √n+1 and √n ≤ 3·10¹²−1 gives T ≤ 3·10¹² — the recipe says T ≤ 3×10¹²−1 \"from n ≤ N₁\" — that's WRONG by 1 unless... — hmm — actually wait: maybe the bridge's hTle is used for the RHUpTo application: ρ.im ≤ T ⟹ re = 1/2 — hRH : RHUpTo (3·10¹²) := ∀ ρ, IsNontrivialZero ρ → |ρ.im| ≤ 3·10¹² → ρ.re = 1/2. The zeros in zeroBothWindow T have |γ| ≤ T+1 ≤ 3·10¹²+1?? — hmm — so actually maybe the bridge's hTle : T ≤ 3·10¹²−1 is used to get |γ| ≤ 3·10¹² for the window zeros: zeroBothWindow T covers |γ| ≤ T+1?? — with T ≤ 3·10¹²−1: |γ| ≤ T+1 ≤ 3·10¹² ✓ — so the bridge NEEDS T ≤ 3·10¹²−1 (so that T+1 ≤ 3·10¹² for RHUpTo). And T ≤ √n+1 with √n ≤ 3·10¹²−1 gives T ≤ 3·10¹² — INSUFFICIENT by the same slack.\n\nHmm — but wait — actually — n ≤ N₁ = (3·10¹²−1)² — if n < N₁ slightly... — the issue is only at the very top of the range. Hmm — but actually — hold on: T ≤ √n + 1 where √n ≤ 3·10¹²−1 — T ≤ 3·10¹². For the bridge I need T ≤ 3·10¹²−1 — i.e., √n + 1 ≤ 3·10¹²−1 ⟺ √n ≤ 3·10¹²−2 ⟺ n ≤ (3·10¹²−2)². But n can be as large as (3·10¹²−1)² > (3·10¹²−2)². CONFLICT at the very top: for n ∈ ((3·10¹²−2)², (3·10¹²−1)²], the bridge's hTle fails?!\n\nHmm wait — let me recheck: SfBoundProp's range: (n:ℝ) ≤ (3·10¹²−1)². T ∈ [√n, √n+1]. Bridge needs T ≤ 3·10¹²−1. Since T ≤ √n+1 ≤ (3·10¹²−1)+1 = 3·10¹², we have T ≤ 3·10¹² but need ≤ 3·10¹²−1. GAP of 1.\n\nHmm — but the ii′-6-b bridge was DESIGNED for this fold (session-038) — surely this was accounted. Let me look at how the bridge's hTle is actually USED — maybe hTle : T ≤ 3·10¹²−1 is just one option and the actual requirement is |γ| ≤ 3·10¹² for window zeros: zeroBothWindow T — let me check zeroBothWindow's def — if it's |γ| ≤ T (not T+1), then |γ| ≤ T ≤ 3·10¹² needs T ≤ 3·10¹² ✓ — but the hypothesis is written as T ≤ 3·10¹²−1... — let me look at the bridge's proof to see what it really needs. Actually — hmm — simplest: check zeroBothWindow_finite/zeroBothWindow def.","signature":""},{"type":"text","text":"Checking the bridge's actual T-range requirement vs what T ≤ √n+1 gives at the top of the range."},{"type":"tool_use","id":"Grep_162","name":"Grep","input":{"pattern":"def zeroBothWindow|zeroBothWindow_finite|hTle","path":"D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiAssembly.lean","output_mode":"content","-A":6,"head_limit":50},"extra_content":null}]