Current task: —

← Session 30 — ii′-5e squeeze capstone + 5f perimeter repair

#1763 assistant 2026-08-24 11:50:01.465 UTC · 287→711 tok open ⤢
thinking (1228 chars)
Now the line 671 error: `linear_combination hrec` in hdecomp — "ring failed, ring expressions not equal". The hdecomp goal after rw [hr1, hr0]: digamma w − digamma w₀ = (log(w+2) − log w₀) + ((1/2)/w₀ − (1/2)/(w+2)) − w⁻¹ − (w+1)⁻¹ + ((digamma(w+2) − log(w+2) + (1/2)/(w+2)) − (digamma w₀ − log w₀ + (1/2)/w₀)). linear_combination hrec: hrec : digamma (w+2) = digamma w + (w⁻¹ + (w+1)⁻¹). goal_diff − (hrec_diff) should be ring-zero: goal_diff = ψw − ψw₀ − (log(w+2) − log w₀) − ((1/2)/w₀ − (1/2)/(w+2)) + w⁻¹ + (w+1)⁻¹ − (r1-exp − r0-exp) where r1-exp = ψ(w+2) − log(w+2) + (1/2)/(w+2), r0-exp = ψ w₀ − log w₀ + (1/2)/w₀. = ψw − ψw₀ − log(w+2) + log w₀ − (1/2)/w₀ + (1/2)/(w+2) + w⁻¹ + (w+1)⁻¹ − ψ(w+2) + log(w+2) − (1/2)/(w+2) + ψ w₀ − log w₀ + (1/2)/w₀ = ψw − ψ(w+2) + w⁻¹ + (w+1)⁻¹. hrec_diff = ψ(w+2) − ψw − w⁻¹ − (w+1)⁻¹. goal_diff + hrec_diff = 0 ✓. So linear_combination should be `linear_combination -hrec` (coefficient −1)! I wrote `linear_combination hrec` — wrong sign. Fix: `linear_combination -hrec`. Wait — goal_diff = ψw − ψ(w+2) + w⁻¹ + (w+1)⁻¹ = −(hrec_diff) — so goal_diff = −1·(hrec_lhs − hrec_rhs) — linear_combination checks goal_diff = Σ cᵢ(hᵢ_diff): −hrec gives c = −1 ✓. So `linear_combination -hrec`.
The linear_combination sign is wrong (goal_diff = −hrec_diff). Fixing both.
tool: Edit
input
{
  "file_path": "D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiTightR.lean",
  "old_string": "    rw [hr1, hr0]\n    linear_combination hrec",
  "new_string": "    rw [hr1, hr0]\n    linear_combination -hrec"
}
raw content_json (database row)
[{"type":"thinking","thinking":"Now the line 671 error: `linear_combination hrec` in hdecomp — \"ring failed, ring expressions not equal\". The hdecomp goal after rw [hr1, hr0]:\ndigamma w − digamma w₀ = (log(w+2) − log w₀) + ((1/2)/w₀ − (1/2)/(w+2)) − w⁻¹ − (w+1)⁻¹ + ((digamma(w+2) − log(w+2) + (1/2)/(w+2)) − (digamma w₀ − log w₀ + (1/2)/w₀)).\n\nlinear_combination hrec: hrec : digamma (w+2) = digamma w + (w⁻¹ + (w+1)⁻¹). goal_diff − (hrec_diff) should be ring-zero:\ngoal_diff = ψw − ψw₀ − (log(w+2) − log w₀) − ((1/2)/w₀ − (1/2)/(w+2)) + w⁻¹ + (w+1)⁻¹ − (r1-exp − r0-exp)\nwhere r1-exp = ψ(w+2) − log(w+2) + (1/2)/(w+2), r0-exp = ψ w₀ − log w₀ + (1/2)/w₀.\n= ψw − ψw₀ − log(w+2) + log w₀ − (1/2)/w₀ + (1/2)/(w+2) + w⁻¹ + (w+1)⁻¹ − ψ(w+2) + log(w+2) − (1/2)/(w+2) + ψ w₀ − log w₀ + (1/2)/w₀\n= ψw − ψ(w+2) + w⁻¹ + (w+1)⁻¹.\nhrec_diff = ψ(w+2) − ψw − w⁻¹ − (w+1)⁻¹.\ngoal_diff + hrec_diff = 0 ✓. So linear_combination should be `linear_combination -hrec` (coefficient −1)! I wrote `linear_combination hrec` — wrong sign. Fix: `linear_combination -hrec`.\n\nWait — goal_diff = ψw − ψ(w+2) + w⁻¹ + (w+1)⁻¹ = −(hrec_diff) — so goal_diff = −1·(hrec_lhs − hrec_rhs) — linear_combination checks goal_diff = Σ cᵢ(hᵢ_diff): −hrec gives c = −1 ✓. So `linear_combination -hrec`.","signature":""},{"type":"text","text":"The linear_combination sign is wrong (goal_diff = −hrec_diff). Fixing both."},{"type":"tool_use","id":"Edit_255","name":"Edit","input":{"file_path":"D:\\Python\\Quantum\\research\\lean\\NguyenRH1\\NguyenRH1\\LiTightR.lean","old_string":"    rw [hr1, hr0]\n    linear_combination hrec","new_string":"    rw [hr1, hr0]\n    linear_combination -hrec"},"extra_content":null}]